.

Showing posts with label upper west side. Show all posts
Showing posts with label upper west side. Show all posts

Wednesday

Queen Anne Sisters at Nos. 251-255 W. 70th Street



In the last two decades of the 19th century, developers on the Upper West Side grabbed up long rows of property and erected speculative rowhouses.  Quite often their architects created enclaves of harmonious structures that flowed together almost as a unit—each standing on its own merit; but architecturally similar to its neighbors.  In 1885 architect W. H. W. Youngs would go a step further.

Developer E. Stanton Riker commissioned Youngs to design three rowhouses on West 70th Street, Nos. 251 through 255.  The playful Queen Anne style had caught on among those daring enough to step out of the more formal residential box; and Youngs turned to this style for the houses.  His design resulted in the three residences pretending to be one grand home.

Completed in 1886 the brick, brownstone and terra cotta houses rather surprisingly rejected the asymmetry associated with Queen Anne.  Youngs liberally splashed Romanesque Revival into the design in the form of hefty arches at the parlor floor (including the great span that served as the entrance for No. 253) and a gaping arch below the central, terra cotta-filled gable.  He successfully created the illusion of a single, imposing mansion.


The three houses became home to upscale, respectable families.  By 1895 when Michael Giblin sold No. 251 to John Noble Golding, the Rev. Claudius M. Roome and his wife lived next door and Harvard graduate John O. Powers lived in No. 255.

John Noble Golding was a highly respected real estate broker with an office at No. 9 Pine Street far downtown.  Educated at Trinity School, he was a member of the Lawyers’, Army and Navy, Colonial, New York Yacht and the New York Athletic Clubs.  Golding was also a member of the American Geographical and Numismatic Societies.

Not only was Golding responsible for massive real estate deals like the Equitable Company’s purchase of its Nassau and Liberty Street site; the sale of the Roman Catholic Orphan Asylum on Fifth Avenue for $125 million, and the New York Yacht Club’s property; he sold sites to some of Manhattan’s wealthiest citizens for their mansions.  Included in his client list were Edward Berwin, Charles T. Yerkes, Howard Gould, Stuyvesant Fish, Perry Belmont, George Baker, Joseph Pulitzer and Thoams F. Ryan to name just a few.

As was the case with all the wives of moneyed businessmen, Mabel Golding busied herself with charities.  One of her favorites was the House of Refuge for Women, at Hudson, New York.  The children of these impoverished women were often overlooked and in 1898 Mabel sent off eight bibs, books, wagons and other toys to the House of Refuge.

The year before her donation, Claudius M. Roome, living next door, had been appointed the new curate of Christ Church, then standing at the corner of the Boulevard (later renamed Broadway) and 71stStreet.  Born into a prominent old Dutch family, he graduated from Columbia College and Columbia Law School.  Having practiced law for a few years, he gave it up to enter the General Theological Seminary.

Roome’s father had been an important businessman and it was most likely the family's wealth rather than his church salary that enabled him to live in the upscale home.

The outwardly-serene home life of the Goldings, with their daughter Mabel, was shattered in 1904 when John Golding moved out.  Finally, in 1910, Mabel filed a separation suit to ensure her financial survival.  The New-York Tribune published the scandalous headline “Wife Sues J. N. Golding.  Manager of Astor Estate Defendant in Separation Suit.”

Millionaire real estate man John N. Golding would tire of his wife.  The Successful American, January 1903 (copyright expired)
Unexpectedly at the time, the title of the 70thStreet home was in John’s name, not his wife’s.  Mabel, with no legal expectations of income, testified that John Golding had $3 million in real and personal property.  The terms of the separation required him to convey the title to Mable and to continue paying off the $15,000 mortgage.

The unsuspecting Mabel Golding was no doubt shocked and humiliated when, in 1918, the house was sold at auction for $14,000—less than the mortgage which her husband had decided not to pay.  She took her husband to court again, suing for the $15,000 (about $220,000 today).

Her millionaire husband apparently came through and Mabel and her daughter retained possession of the house.  She would remain in the house another two years before selling it in April 1920.  Although the new owner, Taylor Holmes, promised he “would occupy,” he resold it a month later.

Hiding under the vines that crawl up the facade, the pressed metal bay can be seen in autumn.  http://www.luxurynewyorkcondominium.com/condo/251-west-70th-street-new-york

By now Rev. Roome had moved on and F. K. Kraetzer, Jr. owned No. 253.  Mrs. R. A. Du Foureq was leasing it at the time that Mabel Golding moved away.  A year earlier No. 255 had fallen victim to a trend that was sweeping over the Upper West Side.  In 1919 real estate operators Houghton Company announced that the house was “being altered into small suites.”

That year The Cornell Alumni News reported that Ensign William F. Tufts had been released from active service in the Naval Reserve and “is now with the McCandless plant of the Westinghouse Lamp Company.”  He was among the first tenants in the newly-converted house.   Another resident held a related job.  M. H. Naigles, XV worked in the installation department of Western Electric Co. “on the automatic phones.”

Nos. 251 and 253 held out as single family homes for a few more years.  In 1937 the former Golding house was home to Mr. and Mrs. Frank Seitz.  The couple had met a colorful acquaintance through a mutual friend around 1930.  Mrs. Muriel Du Pont Bergman told them she was the illegitimate daughter of Delaware Senator T. Coleman Du Pont. 

Now, following the senator’s death, Mrs. Bergman appeared with a letter showing that she had inherited about $40 million from the estate.  Happy and excited, she asked the Seitz couple if they would loan her $15,000.  If so, she would generously repay them with $1 million from the inheritance.

The couple turned over their entire life’s savings to Muriel Bergman.  On August 28, 1937 the 50-year old con artist was arrested in Portland, Oregon on charges of forging the inheritance letter.

Two years later the Seitzes were gone and the house was sold at auction.  It was won by Gus Trachtenburg for $5,700—a fraction of the $17,000 assessed value.  It was converted in 1941 to two apartments in the basement, three furnished rooms on the first floor, and four furnished rooms on each floor above.  In 1945 No. 253 was divided into apartments; two per floor except the third floor which had four furnished rooms.

At least one relic of Mabel Golding's house survives.  http://olshan.com/property.php?id=6557
By the 21st century Youngs’s brilliant design had been viciously abused.  Only a few of the stained glass panels survive, a regrettable picture window was installed on the third floor of No. 255, and the stoops of the end houses were removed.  Nos. 251 and 253, still apartment buildings, were joined internally in 1978.


Despite it all, W. H. W. Youngs’s arresting triple residence still manages to catch the eye.

non-credited photographs taken by the author

The Robt. M. Van Arsdale House -- No. 276 W 71st Street


Like a still-proud dowager fallen on hard times, a sadly abused townhouse sits quietly on West 71st Street, overshadowed by a soaring apartment building next door.  Still wearing the few ornaments she has left, it is not hard to imagine her young and beautiful.

No. 276 West 71st Street started life in 1886 when architect Edward L. Angell designed four similar Romanesque Revival homes for speculative developers Fonner & Lowther.  The Upper West Side was emerging as an exciting new residential district and, like Fonner & Lowther, developers were snapping up abutting building plots to erect harmonious residential projects.

Completed in 1887, like its three neighbors No. 276 would stray slightly from pure Romanesque Revival.  A panel below the gable opening of saw-tooth brickwork showed a Queen Anne influence and there were suggestions of neo-Tudor and Gothic Revival thrown in.  The two-story base, including the basement, was clad in rough-cut brownstone that carried on to the dogleg stoop.  A bay window, tucked within a hefty stone arch, featured a stained glass fanlight.    The house stood out with its heavy stone oriel, the thick foliated support of which engulfed the entrance transom.   Here were two charming sculpted portraits of children, looking away from one another and graced by a necklace of carved brownstone.  Above it all a robust gable nearly hid the slate-tiled mansard roof.


Fonner & Lowther targeted upper-middle class families.  No. 276, completed in 1887, became the home of Robert M. Van Arsdale and his wife, the former Eugenie Humphreville.  Wealthy enough to be included in the Social Register, they both had impressive pedigrees.

An old Dutch family, the Van Arsdales were best remembered for John Jacob Van Arsdale, a young sailor during the American Revolution who would later become a captain in the U.S. Navy.   On November 25, 1783 the last longboat filled with British soldiers left New York Harbor, after occupying the city for seven years.   The date would become known as Evacuation Day and was more highly celebrated than Independence Day for decades.

Before leaving, the British attempted to prevent the hoisting of the American flag over Fort George (now known as Battery Park).  They had removed the halyards so the colors could not be hoisted, then greased the pole for good measure.  John Jacob Van Arsdale tried three times to scale the pole, while General George Washington and his staff looked on.  Finally someone ran to an iron maker and returned with heavy nails and cleats.

With these in his pockets, Van Arsdale started up again with a new halyard tied around his waist.  As he climbed, he drove a nail in—one at the left, then one at the right—until he had reached the top where he installed the halyard.  When he reached the ground Washington and the growing crowd erupted in applause.  The American flag with its 13 stars and stripes was hauled up as 13 cannons fired from the fort.

Every year thereafter, until the early 20thcentury, a Van Arsdale descendent would hoist the American flag at Battery Park on Evacuation Day.  The New York Times would later remember “In later years the Old Guard would parade down to the Battery, with thousands of residents behind and with detachments of troops from other States taking part.  Several Presidents attended the ceremony.  And always some member of the Van Arsdale family would be there to do his part.”

Eugenie’s family history was as impressive.  The daughter of Thomas Liberty Humphreville and Anna Eliza Oliphant, she was a member of the Daughters of the American Revolution.   She was a descendant of Jonathan R. Oliphant, Captain of the 2nd Regiment of the Burlington Co. Militia Company.  Wounded in battle, his private papers showed that he gave most of his fortune for the cause of American independence.

The upper stories have received a coating of plum-colored paint and the stained glass fanlight (lower right) has been blocked up.
Robert Van Arsdale was the owner and publisher of The American Engineering and Railroad Journal.  He had begun his career as a staff journalist of the Railroad Gazette in 1875.  By 1881 when he left to start his own publication, he had amassed a small fortune.  Railway Age and Railway Review said “…his use of the first large sum of money, got by frugality and hard work, was characteristic.  He used it all in buying a city house for his mother.  She had always wanted a city house.  Then he saved for himself and bought the publication with which his name has since been associated.”

Now he turned his attentions to a city house for himself and his wife.  While they participated in the expected activities of well-to-do citizens—Eugenie was a member of the New York Peace Society, for instance—the childless couple led an understated life.   Railway Age said he was a “valuable citizen who quietly does his work, with few public appearances.”

One somewhat public appearance for Van Arsdale came in 1895 when he was summoned to serve on a Grand Jury.  The jurymen had a lot on their plate that December.  Judge Cowing mentioned the increasing crime in the city as he addressed them.  “There seems to be an epidemic of crime by violence, such as assaults, highway robbery, and burglary.” 

On November 23, 1909 the 61-year old publisher arrived home.   “Hardly had he reached his home and taken off his overcoat when he complained of feeling ill,” said Electrical Review and Western Electrician.   He sat in a chair, talking to Eugenie when, according to The Sun the following day, “he became unconscious and sank to the floor.”  Dr. George H. Mallet was called; but before he arrived Robert M. Van Arsdale was dead.

The publisher was the victim of a heart attack.  Electrical Review later explained that he “had been working hard for months past, and it is believe that overwork was indirectly the cause of his sudden death.”

Eugenie was now 75 years old.   By 1913 she shared the house at least for a while with Blanche Ostertag, who either rented a room or was a companion of the elderly widow.  Ostertag was a sculptress and painter who had studied in Paris.  Among her works was the mural decoration for the New Amsterdam Theater. 

As the neighborhood around Eugenie Van Arsdale changed, she lived on in the West 71st Street house.  Many of the 19th century rowhouses were demolished to be replaced by modern apartment buildings while others were converted to apartments.  But the Van Arsdale house remained.

In 1934 a reporter for The New York Times heard of the now-forgotten tradition of a Van Arsdale hoisting the American flag on Evacuation Day—a holiday no longer celebrated.   “Records indicate that up to twenty years ago the lineal descendants of John Jacob Van Arsdale kept the tradition alive,” said the newspaper on November 26 that year.  “Then it died.” 

In his attempt to discover what happened to the patriotic tradition, the reporter searched for members of the Van Arsdale family.   He came across Eugenie’s name and visited the house.

“Up at 276 West Seventy-first Street, in a lonely old house near the river, where she has lived more than half a century, is Mrs. Robert M. Van Arsdale.  But Mrs. Van Arsdale is in her 100th year, hard of hearing and bedridden.”

The journalist spoke to a servant.  “'She does remember little things now and then, about the Revolution,’ confided a white-haired housekeeper, ‘but she never said anything about that flag in all the years I’ve know her and I couldn’t ask her now.'”
Eugenie had been his last hope.  “So, it seems, the tradition is dead, and no one quite knows why,” he concluded.

Almost a year to the day following that article, on November 12, 1935, the newspaper reported “Mrs. Eugenie Van Arsdale, wife of the late Robert M. Van Arsdale, passed on at her home, Saturday, Nov. 9.”  On Thursday her funeral was held in the house where she had lived since 1887.

It was, in effect, the funeral for the house as a private home as well.  It was quickly renovated to furnished rooms—three each in the basement and parlor level; four on the second and third floors; while the new owners took the top floor.

The defacement of paint and linoleum to Eugenie Van Arsdale's interiors is heart-breaking.  photo www.blocksy.com

The Van Arsdale house is still rented as apartments.  Its brick and crumbling brownstone have been painted, the bay window replaced by flat openings more expected in a reformatory; and the striking stained glass fanlight has been removed and plastered over.  But despite the heartless neglect; Edward L. Angell’s fanciful design shines through.

non-credited photographs by the author

Monday

The Scandalous Love Nest at No. 323 West 74th Street


Restoration continued in 2012 -- photo by Alice Lum
As the 20th century approached, sumptuous mansions—many of them free-standing—were rising along Riverside Drive.  The recently completed Riverside Park and the magnificent views across the Hudson River created a viable rival to upper Fifth Avenue as the city’s most exclusive address.


As mansions crept up the Drive, the New York Orphan Asylum was in the way.   The orphanage building filled the block between 73rd and 74th Streets, and the institution owned the block directly north, between 74th and 75th Streets.   In 1893 the Asylum put the block front on the northern side of 74th Street for sale.   Despite the institution across the street, it was a superb opportunity for developers or potential homeowners.

Grand houses quickly filled the northern side of 74th Street, despite the Orphan Asylum across the street -- photo Museum of the City of New York
A group of eight millionaires formed a syndicate and purchased the land with the intention of erecting fashionable residences for themselves and sharing the profits on any additional homes.  They divided the block into eleven building lots ranging according to their needs from 22 to 30 feet wide.   The syndicate then commissioned architect C. P. H. Gilbert to design the row of homes.  Each would be, according to an announcement in the Real Estate Record & Guide, “of the highest order.”

Gilbert had designed several mansions by now, and would soon be responsible for some of the most lavish homes in the city including the French Gothic Isaac Fletcher chateau.   For the row on 74thStreet he would create eleven individually designed residences, none of which would hog the architectural spotlight.

Completed in 1896 they stretched from No. 303 to No. 323, nearest the Drive.  While each of the other mansions was faced in white limestone or buff-colored brick, No. 323 was dressed in red brick—a noticeable punctuation mark for the row.   The house sat on a white marble base above shallow steps leading back from the sidewalk.  Doric columns upheld two stories of bowed façade that created a sheltered portico.   White marble quoins ran zipper-like up with sides creating a pleasant contrast with the red brick.

photo by alice Lum
The mansion became home to William Crittenden Adams.   Born in San Francisco, Adams had a Civil Engineering degree from the Columbia University School of Mines.    Six years before the house on 74th Street was built, he formed a partnership with his brother, Samuel F. Adams, as operators and speculators in Manhattan real estate.   By now a millionaire, he moved in with his wife, Grace Fairchild James Adams, and their three impressively-named children, Crittenden Hull, James Fairchild and Darwin James Adams.   Adams was apparently busy in the neighborhood for in his will he bequeathed the house and lot at No. 259 West 74thStreet, a block away, to his son.

photo "Universities and Their Sons" 1900 (copyright expired)
Adams was a member of several of the most exclusive men’s clubs in town, including the Union League Club.  But it was his love and expertise of yachting for which he was best known.  Adams was a member of the Atlantic Yacht Club and the Seawanhaka Corinthian Yacht Club.   

While Adams was busy sailing and developing real estate, the New York Orphan Asylum took advantage of soaring real estate values.   In 1901 it sold the entire block, from 73rdto 74th Streets and Riverside Drive to West End Avenue to steel magnate Charles M. Schwab.  The industrialist paid $865,000 for the block—the most ever spent on a building lot.   The houses along 74thStreet which had faced the orphanage would, by 1906, overlook the largest, most sumptuous mansion ever constructed in New York City.

For a few years as his gargantuan French Renaissance chateau was being built, Schwab rented No. 323.  The location, directly across the street from the construction site, offered him unparalleled ability to oversee the massive project.

Gilbert focused attention on minute details like the lace-like carving along the window framing and the intricate fruit garland of the keystone -- photo by Alice Lum
Robert E. Tod purchased the house after Schwab moved into his new mansion.   Tod, with his brother John Kennedy Tod, ran the banking firm of J. S. Kennedy & Company which was founded by their uncle, John Stewart Kennedy.    Like Adams, Robert E. Tod was a major player in the yachting community.

While he was Commodore of the Atlantic Yacht Club at the turn of the century, he was instrumental in organizing an international yacht race that involved the German Emperor.  He offered prizes for the winners in a series of ocean races off the coast of Sandy Hook, New Jersey.  The regatta caught the attention of Sir Thomas Lipton of England while he was visiting in 1903.

Sir Thomas was impressed with the fervent interest in the races and offered a cup for a transatlantic race managed by the Atlantic Yacht Club.   Tod was put in an uncomfortable situation when a representative of Emperor Wilhelm II arrived, offering an imperial cup as the main prize.  With apparently delicate diplomacy Tod convinced Sir Thomas Lipton to withdraw his offer of the silver cup so as not to offend the monarch.

In 1913 Tod offered the house at No. 323 West 74thStreet to a real estate firm as partial payment for an apartment building.    The company quickly resold it in December for $125,000.   The purchaser’s name was kept secret, causing much speculation.    The Sunmused “There is one other real estate mystery in Manhattan.  It involves the ownership of the fine dwelling at 323 West Seventy-fourth street…Various stories have been heard as to the real buyer, but none of them could be verified.  In fact, as has been said, it is one of the mystery properties of the city.”

The mystery would not be solved for years; and it would result in delicious fodder for parlor gossip.

When industrialist Jay Gould died in 1892 he left a staggering fortune of approximately $72 million to be divided among his six children.  While daughter Helen remained in the Fifth Avenue mansion living quietly and devoting herself to charity, her siblings, as later reported in a newspaper, “went out in the world.”  Among them was brother George.

George married Edith Kingdon and the couple had seven children.  But by now Edith’s once-striking figure was gone.  The socialite was obese and George’s eye began to wander.    That wandering eye landed on showgirl Guinevere Sinclair, a “Gaiety Girl” dancer.  Despite her career choice, Sinclair had been reared in a prominent family and her grandfather, Sir Edward Sinclair, had been Provost of Trinity College in Dublin.

The young and beautiful Guinevere Sinclair was the recipient of the house at No. 323 West 74th Street—a gift of her new lover.   A son, George Sinclair, was born on April 15, 1915, then a daughter, Jane, in 1917.  Gould also purchased a magnificent Tudor-style country estate in Rye, New York for his lover.  The Gould family, including Edith, was well aware of the arrangement and the children were known among the family as “George’s bastards.”  Only New York society was kept in the dark. 

Edith tried valiantly to lose weight and regain her husband’s favor.  She went through diets and massages and took up golf.   Her attempts to appear thin included wearing a tortuously tight rubber suit under her clothing.    During a golf game in November 1921 with George, Edith suddenly dropped to the ground, dead of a heart attack.   Beneath her golf costume was the suffocating rubber suit.

Within six months George Gould married Guinevere Sinclair in a five-minute ceremony in Lakewood, New Jersey, about the time that another daughter, also named Guinevere, was born.    The newly-weds immediately sailed for Europe and clubrooms and ballrooms of New York society buzzed with rumors regarding the unknown bride.

Although the New-York Tribune reported that “All the mystery surrounding the marriage was swept away yesterday with the discovery of the records pertaining to the wedding on file at the Bureau of Vital Statistics in Trenton, New Jersey, “ it bemoaned that “Very little could be learned here yesterday about the new Mrs. Gould.”   The newspaper disclosed “It was said yesterday by friends of Mr. Gould that the marriage was no surprise to members of the Gould family, although none of them was present at the ceremony.”

The marriage would not last long.  A year later, in May 1923, the 59-year old George Gould died alone in France from heart disease.  It would be the beginning of a bitter fight for the $15 million estate.

The Gould family harbored bitter animosity against the former showgirl and her children.  Gould’s legitimate children fought in court for valuable paintings which they said were given to Edith during his lifetime, and the family mansions in Lakewood, New Jersey and Manhattan.    Finally on June 18, 1925 the estate was settled with Guinevere receiving $1 million in Liberty bonds which George had sent to her just before his death in Paris and a $4 million trust fund for the children.

Guinevere Sinclair Gould did not let grass grow under her feet.   Later that year she married the English viscount George St. John Broderick Dunsford.  Dunsford apparently had an eye for showgirls, for he had recently divorced another former actress.    By 1927 Guinevere, now Lady Dunsford, had purchased Estwell Park, a sprawling estate in Kent, England and lived there with her three children and new husband.

That same year, the house at No. 323 West 74thStreet was divided into “non-housekeeping apartments.”  Five years later the designation was changed to simply “apartments.”  In 2002 architect Allen Strasen was commissioned by owner Van Velle to renovate the home.

Obscured by construction scaffolding are the white marble entrance steps and base -- photo by Alice Lum
A penthouse, invisible from the street, was added to the roof, creating a triplex apartment with the fourth and fifth floors.   Although no longer a private home; the impressive brick and marble exterior has been lovingly preserved.

Sunday

The Claremont Riding Academy - 175 West 89th Street



By 1892 houses and apartment buildings were quickly rising on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. Central Park, completed in 1873, lured developers who built rows of comfortable brownstone residences and luxurious apartments like The Dakota on Central Park West and 72nd Street. The newly established residents all needed adequate stable facilities for their horses and carriages.

On 89th Street, a block and a half from the Park, Edward Bedell erected a handsome stone livery stable. Designed by Frank A. Rooke, whose reputation was made designing stables, the Claremont was five stories tall and boasted an ingenious system of ramps that connected the floors – allowing horses and vehicles to be housed in the basement and on the second floor. Large elevators hoisted more carriages to the upper floors. In all there were 135 stalls for boarding horses.

The unpretentious buff brick building used limestone trim to accent its restrained Romanesque Revival style. A stepped stone arch with a carved horseshoe framed the main entrance. Inside Rooke provided a small riding ring which proved to be somewhat unrealistic.


When completed, Bedell sold the Claremont to millionaire Charles F. Havermeyer, who in turn leased it to the Tallman brothers, Lee and Darius. The brothers operated another livery stables, the Cedarhurst.

Within a decade more automobiles and fewer horses populated New York’s streets. One by one the boarding stables either closed or were converted into garages; as happened to the Cedarhurst in 1910. The Claremont hung on, however.

On January 6, 1928 the then-current owner, Emil Wellner, made an eyebrow-raising announcement. The Claremont was to become a riding academy. Aspiring equestrians were given both private or group lessons in dressage and jumping from a staff of between 15 to 20 instructors. Veteran riders could rent horses for an afternoon ride on Central Park’s bridle path; after negotiating Manhattan traffic from the academy to the park.

Despite the comfortable success of the Claremont Riding Academy, Wellner had bigger plans. Nine years later, in 1937, he filed plans with the city to raze the building and erect a garage. The plans were rejected because the proposed garage was too close to a public school. The Academy lived on.

Wellner sold the Academy to his bookkeeper, Irwin Novogard, in 1943. The building was threatened again when, in 1956, the city proposed a major urban renewal project that would replace the existing buildings in the area with a large public housing project. Within the decade dozens of buildings had been acquired through condemnation, including the Claremont, and many razed. The Academy clung on, existing on a by month-to-month lease.


The fiscal crisis of 1977 forced the city to abandon its public housing designs. Novogard’s son, Paul, quickly sought landmark status from the New York Landmarks Preservation Commission in an effort to prevent any further threats to the building.

All the while young riders were still taking their lessons at the Academy and stalwart horsemen and women braved New York Traffic to ride in Central Park.

Landmark status came in 1990 and, finally, the city sold the building back to Novogard in 1998, 37 years after condemning the structure. A $2 million restoration followed which unfortunately resulted in heavy costs to the Academy in increased real estate taxes and property insurance. And yet the Claremont Riding Academy, the oldest stables in Manhattan, plodded on.


The death blow came for the Academy unexpectedly -- not from the threat of the wrecker’s ball but from the Commissioners of Central Park. The deep cinder bridle paths had historically been maintained solely for the use of horses. But shortly after 2000, the park allowed bicyclists, joggers and pedestrians on the paths and, worse yet, discontinued maintenance. With new congestion – what Paul Novogard termed “a fearful running of the gauntlet” -- coupled with the lack of maintenance, riders could no longer canter along the trails. Patronage at the Claremont fell off.

On April 29, 2007, after 115 years, the Claremont closed its doors forever.

The New York Times commented, “At the very least, the closing of the Claremont stables means that Manhattan is a less surprising place…And so we will never again walk along West 89th Street and be overcome by the deeply nostalgic smell of horses, and may never again have the surprising pleasure of coming upon a horse and rider in the park…New York is certainly a human city, filled as it is with humans. But the loss of this stable makes us wonder whether the city wasn’t more human still when we shared so much more of it with horses.”

After plans to convert the building to apartments fell through, it was purchased by the Stephen Gaynor School, a private school for children with learning difficulties.

Thursday

C P H Gilbert's 1898 No. 312 West 73rd Street


Perhaps most remembered for the lavish mansions he designed on Manhattan’s East Side; C. P. H. Gilbert was equally busy on the West Side during the last years of the 19th century.  In 1897, having just completed the George E.Fahys house next door, Gilbert was at work on No. 312 West 73rdStreet.

William Lee Trenholm had purchased the lot from John J. Sutphen on January 18, 1897.  He paid $30,000 for the land—over $800,000 today.  Gilbert’s design for Trenholm would be starkly different from the limestone-fronted Fahy house.   In the late 1890s, taste in residential architectural style was beginning to inch away from European-inspired design as America rediscovered its roots.   The decade had seen the founding of groups like the Daughters of the American Revolution, the Sons of the American Revolution, and the Society of Colonial Wars.  Before long prim neo-Federal and neo-Georgian mansions of red brick with white limestone or marble trim were rising along Central Park.

But the Trenholm house would go a step further.  While the Renaissance Revival Fahy house was decidedly European; No. 312 West 73rd Street drew its inspiration from the early 18th century streets of New England.    Completed in 1898, the house was both somber and grand in its design.   Four stories of the central section bowed forcefully out, creating a spacious balcony at the fifth floor.  Another balcony at the second floor, created by the Doric-columned portico, was accessed by a dramatic arched doorway.  Gilbert used both brownstone and terra cotta for the sparse ornamentation.

In contrast to his severe exterior, Gilbert lavished the interior with heavy plaster ceiling ornamentation in the form of garlands and floral ropes and installed imported marble mantels.  The French-paneled rooms had intricate parquet floors.  Grand spaces designed for lavish entertaining boasted of the owners’ wealth.

Colonel William Lee Trenholm -- New-York Tribune, January 12, 1901 (copyright expired)

Born in Charleston, South Carolina, Trenholm had been Secretary of the Treasury of the Confederate States under Jefferson Davis; as well as serving as a Colonel in the Confederate Army.  Later he was appointed Controller of the Currency under the first Cleveland Administration.

He had moved to New York in 1889, taking the position of President of the American Surety Company.  The same year that he moved his family into the 73rd Street house, he became President of the North American Trust Company.

Trenholm and his wife, the former Kate Macbeth, had eight children.   The mansion was barely completed by the time of daughter Constance’s marriage to Dr. Russell Bellamy in fashionable St. Thomas’s Church on Fifth Avenue.  The high social caliber of the event was evidenced by names in the wedding party, including J. G. Phelps-Stokes, Joseph Frelinghuysen and Allan Robbins.

Following the ceremony, the Trenholms hosted a “large reception at their new residence,” said The Sun on April 21, 1898.  A long honeymoon for the newlyweds was doubtful.   The U.S.S. Maine had been sunk in Havana Harbor two months earlier; and on the day of the wedding Spain severed diplomatic relations with the U.S. as Congress considered its options.  The Sun wrote “The bridegroom, who is Sergeant of the Hospital Corps of Squadron A, may at any moment have his marching orders.”

 Less than three years later, on New Year’s Day 1901, William Trenholm contracted the grip, which worsened to pneumonia.  The 65-year old’s condition was serious enough to warrant newspaper coverage.  On January 10 The New York Times reported that he was “slightly improved last night.  During the day Col. Trenholm became worse, but rallied during the evening.”   Russell Bellamy, the young doctor who had married his daughter and went off to war attended him along with Drs. Thornley and Gilman W. Thompson.

It was a short-lived rally.  The New-York Tribune reported that “although [his condition] improved slightly…it changed for the worse again Thursday, and all hope was abandoned.”   Early in the morning of the day following The Times article, Trenholm’s wife and children gathered around his bedside.  Only his son, George, who was at school in Charleston and on the way home, was not present as William L. Trenholm died.  The funeral was held in the house the next day, January 11, at 3:00. 

Kate Trenholm left New York and moved back to Charleston into her “fine house at the head of the Battery” as described by The Sun.  The aristocratic Southern woman was highly insulted when her home was raided on April 11, 1903 while other gentlewomen were calling on her.  A South Carolina newspaper said “There was much indignation here to-day when it became known that dispensary constables had invaded the Trenholm home on the hunt for ‘blind tiger’ liquor.”  The newspaper said Kate was “astounded when five rough countrymen called and said they had orders to search the place.  Protests and entreaties were unavailing.”

After their ransacking of the house (The Sun said “They opened wardrobes, scattered clothing and left without finding a trace of whiskey), the constables said that “some grievous mistake had been made in the street number.”   The following day the Chief of the Dispensary made a call on Kate Trenholm with an apology.  The Sun reported “It was not accepted.”

In the meantime the family leased the house on West 73rdStreet.   On August 17, 1902 The New York Times had mentioned that it had been taken “for a term of years at a gross rental of $35,000.”  Albert Sanders, a receiver for bankrupt firms, and his wife lived in the house through 1907.

The cast iron fanlight and unusual bowed entrance doors survive.

In January 1908 the house was offered at auction, and a year later it was resold by the Mutual Life Insurance Co. to  Sailing Baruch, Jr.  The new owner immediately hired architect J. H. Freedlander to update the residence, “including the installation of elevator service,” as reported in The Sun on September 2, 1909.  The remodeling cost Baruch $15,000.

Sailing was one of four sons of Dr. Simon Baruch, an eminent physician and scientist.   Like the Trenholms, he had Southern roots.  His mother, Isabel Wolfe Baruch, was the daughter of South Carolina cotton planter Sailing Wolfe.  His uncle, financier and political consultant Bernard Baruch, gave his name to Baruch College of City University of New York.   

Sailing and his wife had two sons in the house, Donald and Sailing, Jr.  Following Dr. Baruch’s death in June 1921, Sailing’s 72-year old mother—once highly active in music and philanthropy—deteriorated.  The Quarterly Journal of the New York State Historical Society noted “from that time Mrs. Baruch gradually lost strength.”  On November 24, 1921 she died in the West 73rd Street house.

Although he would become president of the Wall Street investment house Baruch Brothers & Co., Inc.; Sailing Baruch was more often in the newspapers for his playboy ways than for more serious endeavors.  On August 13, 1922 the New-York Tribunepointed out that the Baruchs were at the fashionable Paul Smith’s resort in New York and had taken up a new-fangled hobby—home movies.

“Motion picture shows of their own are increasing in favor as a means of entertainment among the campers on the St. Regis chain of lakes and the nearby waters,” said the newspaper.  Some of them hav along movie cameras and are giving jolly little exhibitions of the films they make of their friends in action on the links of the St. Regis River Golf Club and on mountain-climbing trips and other expeditions.”   The Tribune said “Mr. and Mrs. Sailing W. Baruch, of New York, who are here for the season with their sons, Donald and Sailing jr., are first among the members of the cottage colony at Paul Smith’s Hotel to adopt private movies.”
Before long newspapers would be more interested in Sailing’s dating than in his home movies.  The now-single Baruch was fodder for gossip on May 29, 1932 when Nancy Randolph, writing in the Chicago Sunday Tribune wrote “Incidentally, they have even rumored Doris Duke as the wife-to-be of Sailing Baruch Jr.  It may be so, but then, knowing Sailing, a plump, genial and not loquacious young man, we can hardly see the tall and sensible Doris enamored of the about town Sailing.” 

The same year that Nancy Randolph circulated the Duke-Baruch rumor, the 73rd Street house was purchased by Celia Frender and converted to apartments—one on the first floor and two on the upper levels.   Frender would retain ownership of the property for three decades, selling it in April 1966 for $140,000.

The purchaser was the unlikely Institute for Human-Animal Relationship, Inc.   The organization, suspected to be somewhat shady by some officials, was described by Attorney General Louis J. Lefkowitz a year later as “a self-styled charitable organization set up to foster understanding between people and pets.”  But the tax-exempt status which the Institute obtained for itself raised Lefkowitz’s suspicions. 

An investigation showed that although it had collected $350,000 by December 1968, only occasionally had it distributed “birdseed, bird cages and fish tanks.”  The Attorney General alleged that donations were ending up in the pockets of the Institute’s promoters.  Armed with this evidence, Finance Administrator Fioravante g. Perrotta revoked the organization’s tax-exempt status.
Much of the interior detailing survives -- http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/312-W-73rd-St-APT-1A-New-York-NY-10023/2110993857_zpid/
In 1977 the former mansion was converted once again—this time to four apartments on the ground floor and three each on the upper floors.   Charles Pierrepont Henry Gilbert’s highly uncharacteristic structure has undergone some abuse; yet much of the interior detailing survives and the exterior retains its integrity.

non-credited photographs taken by the author

Monday

The 1876 Christ & Saint Stephen's Church -- 129 W 69th Street


When the Church of the Transfiguration, fondly called The Little Church Around the Corner, commissioned William H. Day to design an uptown chapel, the architect obviously took inspiration from Transfiguration’s charming 1848 building on East 29th Street.

That structure, designed by F. C. Withers, was described by some as “a holy cucumber vine.” It’s low, country architecture recalling a rural English parish church. Likewise, while perhaps not quite as picturesque, Day’s Transfiguration Chapel, sitting back on a broad lawn, presented a pastoral image oddly out of place on busy West 69th Street.

Completed in 1876, Transfiguration Chapel was intended to serve the church’s parishioners who moved northward, out of the Murray Hill area. The long, low building with its many peaks and gables, its clay tile roof and unassuming bell tower was an obvious extension of the Little Church Around the Corner downtown.

Although the chapel was successful, by 1897 Transfiguration sought to sell its uptown outpost. On March 17 The New York Times said “Various reports have been circulated recently as to the future of Transfiguration Chapel, at the Boulevard and Sixty-ninth Street, and Protestant Episcopal church circles in the diocese are wondering what will be the future of this interesting adjust to the up-town work of ‘The Little Church Around the Corner.’”


The article mentioned that St. Stephen’s Church on 46th Street was interested in the property, valued at around $60,000. St. Stephen’s congregation had outgrown its building; yet there were stumbling blocks to be overcome. The parish of Transfiguration Chapel ardently wished to keep their home and was attempting to raise the money to purchase it from the mother church. In addition, the neighboring Christ Church, two blocks away, was defiantly opposed to the sale to St. Stephen’s.

“It is contended that there is not room in that district for two churches of the same type of churchmanship,” said The Times. “Both are classed as exponents of the Low Church wing, while the present Transfiguration Chapel belongs to the High Church order, and would, naturally, draw to itself only people of its own way of thinking in the neighborhood.”

The bickering between the church groups was closely followed by the press for weeks, until at last St. Stephen’s won the right to purchase. The congregation hired architect J. D. Fouquet to carefully remodel the building with respect to Day’s original design. Their first service was held on October 3, 1897.

Relations between St. Stephen’s and its neighbor, Christ Church, remained strained and in 1905 Christ Church sued St. Stephen’s for infringing on parish boundaries. The suit was dismissed and the two churches continued in their tense coexistence.

Ironically, it was hard times that brought the two groups together in the 1960s. When John D. Rockefeller III built Lincoln Center, he used eminent domain to demolish seventeen residential blocks, displacing over 7000 families. At the same time maintenance costs for the church buildings increased. With decimated congregations, higher overhead and reduced income, the two parishes realized the necessity to merge.

In 1975 they became Christ & Saint Stephen’s Church. After nearly a century their uneasy truce became a marriage.

Structural deterioration resulted a ceiling collapse in 2004 which necessitated a total demolition of the ceiling. A complete restoration of the interior then ensued. In the process, original 19th Century stenciling was discovered which was restored in sito and replicated elsewhere in the interior.


The quaint little church still sits behind its low stone wall like a slice of English countryside dropped among Manhattan high rises; a picturesque and surprising treasure at 129 West 69th Street.


Saturday

The 1897 Fahys Mansion -- No. 310 W 73rd Street


In 1896 construction began on George E. Fahy’s new home at No. 310 West 73rd Street.  At a time when the Upper West Side erupted in eccentric residential architecture sprouting gargoyles, turrets and carved grotesques; mansion architect C. P. H. Gilbert had designed a formal Renaissance Revival residence that would have been quite at home on the opposite side of Central Park.

The ever-active George Ernest Fahys was Vice-President of the Fayhs Watch Case Co. at No. 54 Maiden Lane; President of the Brooklyn Watch Case Co.; President of the jewelry firm Alvin Mfg. Co.; Vice-President of the Montauk Steamboat Co.; Treasure of the Sag Harbor Water Co.; and Vice-President of the Jewellers’ Association and Board of Trade.  The Fahys family moved into the 16-room house in 1897.

Unlike Gilbert’s wealthy patrons on the East Side, it would seem that Fahys watched costs closely.  The house was clad in iron-spot Roman brick chosen to closely match the rusticated limestone base.   And elaborate terra cotta embellishments took the place of more costly carved stone.  Nevertheless, Gilbert had produced a striking five-story mansion appropriate to the owner’s wealth and position.

Three stories projected away from the façade not only to create a handsome terrace at the fourth floor, accessed by an elaborate Palladian-style set of openings; but it distinctly separated the main entrance from the service door at the western side.  The shallow stoop and side yard were guarded by limestone walls and iron fencing.

“The entrance is through a door of massive iron grille work into a fine entrance hall paneled in San Domingo mahogany and with ceiling beams of the same wood,” described The New York Times later.  “Back of this are kitchen and pantries large enough to meet the wants of a good-sized hotel.”

The second floor housed the mahogany-paneled library with built in bookcases.  The library engulfed about half of the interior space of that floor.  “Back of this is a daintily furnished drawing room decorated in white,” said the newspaper.  Also on this floor was the nearly-round dining room wainscoted with mahogany interspersed with French vernis Martin-decorated panels.

On the upper three floors were eleven bedrooms and the servants’ rooms.  The New York Times deemed that all of them “except those occupied by the servants, [are] decorated in the most artistic manner.”

George E. Fahys would live in the new mansion only six years.  On February 7, 1903 the Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide noted that he had sold the house to Mrs. Richard C. Veit.   In reality, it was her husband, who was Superintendent of the Foreign Department of the Standard Oil Company, who was the purchaser.  But in the early days of the 20th century, high-end homes were most often put in the name of the wives; thereby providing them additional financial security in the case of the breadwinner’s death.

At the time of the sale, the 73rd Street house had unobstructed views of the Hudson River and the New Jersey palisades.   The Times would later mention “Only one house stands between it and Riverside Drive, and the front is built out in such a manner that the front windows command the sweep of the drive and the river beyond.”

Directly across the street construction of Charles M. Schwab’s gargantuan block-encompassing mansion was ongoing.  It would be another three years before the multi-millionaire’s massive French Renaissance chateau was completed.

Moving into No. 310 with his parents was 19-year old Arthur S. Veit.   The boy managed to publicly embarrass his family two years later when he was involved in a police raid—and then made matters worse.

The district between 23rd Street and 42ndStreet, from about Fifth to Seventh Avenues was known as the Tenderloin.  Here brothels, illegal gambling houses, and crime-ridden dives were uncontrolled.  Crime and vice thrived with the help of corrupt local police.   Arthur Veit was in the notorious Cairo on Friday night, January 13, when police rushed in.

Among those taken away to the West 30th Street station house were young Veit and a woman of ill-repute.  Arthur pledged “his” house at No. 310 West 73rdStreet as bail to get the two of them out of jail.  It was a bad decision.

On January 15 police interviewed the Standard Oil mogul.  The New York Times reported “In the interview Veit’s father was alleged to have said that he, and not his son, owned the property in Seventy-third Street where they live, and that his son had no right to pledge it for bail.’

Young Veit had not only gotten himself in trouble at home; he was in deeper trouble with the law.  Magistrate Ommen was infuriated at the boy’s insolence.  “I am going up to the Tenderloin Police Station and I am going to investigate this matter thoroughly.  It is very serious,” he told reporters.  “If this man has gone on that bond and did not own the property he has committed a felony, and I shall place the matter in the hands of District Attorney Jerome.  Even though the young man owned the property, he had no legal right to go on the bond, because in the eyes of the law he is a minor at nineteen.”

Later that year, in October, Richard Veit sold the mansion to Congressman Timothy D. Sullivan.  The New York Times said “Mr. Veit is giving up the house because his sons are at college, his daughter was married recently, and only himself and Mrs. Veit, with a corps of servants, remain to occupy it.”

Called by The Times “the original ‘Big Tim’ of New York and ‘Dry Dollar’ of Albany,” Sullivan essentially controlled the Bowery and Lower East Side districts as an important Tammany Hall figure.  His imposing stature led to the “Big Tim” tag.   Born in the infamous Five Points slums, he had risen from a shoeshine boy to a wealthy businessman and influential politician.

Tim Sullivan was a highly-popular Tammany Hall politician among the Bowery and Lower East Side voters. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York   http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYWMXY6B2&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=894
Despite Sullivan’s past involvement in criminal activity and electoral fraud, he was serving in the U.S. Congress when he purchased the 73rdStreet house.   On reporting the sale, The Times said “To make his entry into the upper circles in befitting style Congressman Sullivan has purchased the house at 310 West Seventy-third Street, one of the handsomest residences in the Riverside section.”

Sullivan paid Veit $90,000 for the mansion—about $2.4 million in today’s dollars.  The contract allowed the Veits to stay on in the house until December 14.  The newspaper said “The house is built for entertaining on a large scale…Mr. Veit has in it to-day a fine library and a valuable collection of paintings, said to be one of the best private collections in the city.  These, however, will not pass to the new owner, although it is contemplated that an arrangement will be made by which some of the elaborate furnishings and costly rugs will remain in the house when Mr. Sullivan takes possession.”

The Times poked fun at the man who came from such humble beginnings, saying in a sub-headline “He’ll Now Keep a Butler.”   The article added “While Congressman Sullivan’s new move will no doubt bring dismay to his thousands of friends on the Bowery, it is understood that he will desert them only in the sense of taking up a new abode.”

Like the Veits, however, the Sullivans would remain in the house only three years.  In May 1909 Hannah Sullivan sold the mansion.  It became the home of Henry Zuckerman and his family.   Entertainments in No. 310 West 73rd Street were once again a bit more upscale than they had been during the Sullivan residency.  Mrs. Zuckerman was actively involved in the charitable causes and events expected of the wives of moneyed businessmen.

In December 1910 she was busy with the special performance at the Metropolitan Opera House for the benefit of the Widowed Mothers’ Fund Association.  Among the stars to appear would be Anna Pavlowa.  With her on the committee were wealthy socialites like Mrs. Randolph Guggenheimer, Mrs. Joseph E. Hoffman and Mrs. Daniel Guggenheim.

The house would be the scene of debutante entertainments for daughter Nellie in 1912.  Nellie graduated from Wellesley in June that year.  On December 9 a marathon of activities included a 4:00 to 7:00 reception a theater party, with 50 guests returning to West 73rd Street for supper and a dance.

A year later excitement began all over again when Nellie’s engagement to Arthur J. Cohen was announced.

Although they retained ownership of the house, the Zuckeman family, too, moved on.  In June 1914 Henry Zuckerman leased the mansion to H. J. Wallace; then in October 1916 to Joseph E. O’Kelly and his wife Mercedes.  The O’Kelly family was living in the house when the United States entered World War I.  Joseph John O’Kelly entered the Field Artillery Section of the Reserve Corps of the U.S. Army, rising to 2nd Lieutenant by 1920.

That year, in October, the O’Kellys purchased the house from Henry Zuckerman.   Somewhat unexpectedly the house was soon operated as a high-end boarding house, operated by Mary Lewis.    Leona Jane Hertz was living here in June 1923 when she became engaged to the President of the Chesapeake Export Company, Alfred Ettlinger.   And by 1925 ballerina Princess Caracciolo and her sister conducted a dance studio in the house.

Tragedy would befall another tenant, 23-year old Dorothy Smith, the following year.  Dorothy earned her living as a “cloak model” despite her parents repeated urging “to give up the struggle of trying to earn her own living in the city and return home to stay,” according to The New York Times on September 28, 1926.  The aspiring model insisted on pursuing her dreams, however.  Around the end of June she took an apartment in the former mansion consisting of one room, a kitchenette and a bath.

On September 27 she went to a nightclub, Sophie Tucker’s Playground, on West 52nd Street where two young stock brokers struck up a conversation.   Francis Murphy was 24 years old and John J. Fitzpatrick was 22.   After a while Murphy, who lived at No. 115 East 89th Street, convinced Dorothy that the three should go to his apartment.

Once there, Dorothy discovered that the young brokers’ intentions were anything but respectable.   Trapped in the apartment she fought off their unwanted advances.  Neighbors heard screams and protests coming from the apartment for several minutes; then Dorothy Sullivan threw herself from the fourth floor window to escape.

According to police, “After her leap she managed to crawl a few feet.  Fearing she was about to die, she picked up a slip of paper in the yard and scribbled the word ‘Murphy’ on it with a gold pencil suspended from a chain around her neck.”  Later, at the hospital, she gave the police the full names of her attackers.  Detectives went to the apartment and arrested Murphy and Fitzpatrick.

The men protested their innocence, saying the first they learned of her leap was when they walked into the bedroom and she was not there.   Doctors, in the meantime, held out little hope of Dorothy’s survival.

The coming and going of creative, West Side types would continue for the next decade.  Theodora Irvine conducted a theater studio in the house in the 1930s; and at the same time poet Margaret Belle Houston-Probert was a resident.  Painter Raphael Ellender was living here in 1942.

More notorious and no less tragic was the story of Patrice Leary, the 22-year old teacher who moved in after graduating from Smith College in 1970.   The neighborhood had declined and upon taking the apartment Patrice added a second lock to her door.  But it was not precaution enough.

On Thursday afternoon, October 29 neighbors noticed that her door was ajar.  The New York Times reported that she “was beaten, stabbed repeatedly and strangled manually…The police found the 6-inch blade of a kitchen knife in the dead woman’s chest.”  There was no evidence that she had been sexually molested and a medical examination showed that she was a virgin.

Police theorized that Patrice had entered the apartment with bags of groceries.  She left the door unlocked while she put down the groceries, giving the assailant the opportunity to attack.  The condition of the kitchen spoke of the violent struggle.  “Tables and chairs were over-turned and broken in the room,” said The New York Times on November 1.  A hammer was retrieved with which the young woman’s head had been bludgeoned, a telephone cord had been used to strangle her, and the knife wound penetrated her heart.

Despite the description of a white male in his 20s seen rushing from house, police were baffled.   By November 4 there were 75 men working full time to find the killer and six days later a reward of $1,500 was offered.  The police called Patrice “a fine, decent girl, the kind of person you want to help and protect.”

And yet the case finally went cold.  No one was ever arrested in Patrice Leary’s murder and the reason behind it remains a mystery.


In 1997 the former Fahys mansion was converted to two spacious apartments per floor.  Despite a few exterior alterations, it remains a fine example of C. P. H. Gilbert’s residential work on the Upper West Side.

photographs by the author