.

Showing posts with label neo-grec architecture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label neo-grec architecture. Show all posts

Wednesday

Billy the Oysterman -- No. 11 E. 20th Street





When William Brady began construction of the three-story Italianate rowhouse at No. 11 East 20th Street in 1852, he was a little late to the party.  By now businesses were infiltrating the residential neighborhood between Madison Square and Union Square along Broadway.  No sooner had the brick-faced house been completed in 1853 than tax documents reveal that it housed small shops.

In 1865 the firm of Locke & Craige owned the building.  A year earlier U.S. Congress House Documents documented that the government had paid the firm $721.10 “for a site and building for a post office in the city of New York.”  With the money from selling its building, the company apparently bought No. 11 East 20th.

At some point around 1870 the building got a facelift with neo-Grec lintels over the openings, a pedimented cornice, and a two-story shop front.  By 1900 the neighborhood had become a major shopping district.  That year owner Sarah Hale Witthaus hired contractor James Waddell to install a modern storefront with expansive windows at the second floor.  It attracted a new tenant, furrier Robert Arnold.  On July 1, 1902 Fur Trade Reviewnoted “Mr. Robert Arnold, importing and manufacturing furrier, has removed to exceptionally desirable premises at 11 East Twentieth street, near Broadway.”

The building was sold in 1906 to “an investor.”  Soon Arp Laue signed a 15-year lease on the building for an aggregate rental of $75,000.  The quiet existence of No. 11 East 20th Street was soon to change.

The following year, next door at Nos. 7 and 9, Holtz & Freystedt built an impressive 12-story Beaux Arts building.  The restaurateurs reserved the lower two floors for its French-inspired restaurant. 

In the meantime, German immigrant William T. Ockendorf ran his own restaurant on West Third Street.  Known as “Billy the Oysterman,” he started out small, opening an oyster stand in a basement at Wooster and West Third Streets.  Oysters sold for “a cent a-piece.”  Later he moved his restaurant with its sawdust-covered floors upstairs on West Third Street.  Later The New York Times would reminisce “’Billy the Oysterman’ became an institution known throughout the city.”

In 1910 the man who had started his new life selling oysters for a penny personally walked into the Albany Statehouse to incorporate his business.  He had big plans. 

A year earlier Holtz & Freystedt expanded its restaurant, breaking through the wall to No. 11.  The plan would be short lived, however.  By 1912, with business failing, Holtz & Freystedt abandoned the expanded space.  A year later it closed its doors for good.

As quickly as Holtz & Freystedt evacuated No. 11, Billy the Oysterman moved in.  The New York Times said “The present restaurant of ‘Billy the Oysterman’ offers a sharp contrast with the saw-dust covered floors of the earlier places  It has tiled floors, mounted fish on the walls and expensive furniture.”

The by time Billy the Oysterman moved into No. 11 (lower right) it was already squeezed between towering buildings.  The wall of windows at the second floor and the centered doorway can be seen.  photograph by Wurts Bros from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYWW7A9LU&SMLS=1&RW=1366&RH=631

Billy the Oysterman took up the lower two floors and the top floor was leased to various businesses throughout the years.  Katz & Co., owned by Phil Katz, was here in 1915, according to The American Cloak and Suit Review; and Baumann-Marx Realty Co., Inc. had its offices in the building in 1918.

William T. Ockendorf died on January 20, 1914.  He had amassed an estate equaling over $1 million today “mainly accumulated in the oyster business,” said The Sun on February 1.  Ockendorf left the business to his three sons, George, Harvey and William. 

George Washington Ockendon, the eldest son, took on the sobriquet of Billy the Oysterman.  Like his brothers, he had a public school education and learned the business first-hand.  Despite his sometimes rough-edged demeanor, he was a consummate host. The New York Times remembered on December 11, 1928 “With his brothers, he would personally greet the prominent guests.  Among those who came frequently were Governor Smith, Jack Dempsey, Gene Tunney and leaders of sport, politics and the stage.”

Business flourished, requiring additional staff.  On a single day in 1918 two advertisements appeared in the New-York Tribune.  One read “Kitchenmen Wanted—No Sunday work,” the other simply said “Oysterman—No Sunday work.  Billy the Oysterman.”

George Ockendon not only had a large personality, he had a large physique. The Sun took the opportunity to poke fun at Ockendon’s girth on April 5, 1919 following the auction of actress Marjorie Rambeau’s furniture.

“The big thud on Broadway’s consciousness occurred when Billy the Oysterman, who looks as though he carries a large part of the stock of his restaurant on Twentieth street concealed on his person, bought a huge mahogany chair, formerly the property of Grover Cleveland, with compartments that might be useful before prohibition sets in.  It was whispered that Billy went to the chair—or vice versa—not because he bid $23, but because he was the only one present who could fit its dimensions, Billy breaking the scales at something like 300 pounds.”

The newspaper’s mention of hidden compartments and Prohibition was somewhat foretelling.  The Ockendon brothers had no intention of letting Prohibition put an end to their selling alcohol.  The restaurant’s first brush with dry agents ended with a lucky break.  On April 23, 1921 The Times reported that “Policeman George Chaffers of the East Twenty-second Street Station said he had found three sealed bottles of whisky in a handbag in the apartment of Ockendon at the East Twentieth Street address.”

The policeman did not have a search warrant and Judge Thomas J. Nolan begrudgingly discharged George Ockendon.  Nolan was not happy.  “This testimony opens up another angle of the situation.  The policeman acting under orders is not to be criticised, but the orders seem to be absolutely contrary to law and repulsive to the Constitution.”

Jacketed waiters serve in the handsome downstairs room.  The staircase to the second floor dining room can be seen behind the oyster bar.  photograph Gas Logic magazine, June 1918 (copyright expired)

Billy the Oysterman would not continue to be so lucky.  George used the third floor and basement to warehouse liquor and established a “private bar” in his office for trusted patrons.  On October 24, 1922 Prohibition agents purchased drinks served by waiter Otto Seidt.  The following day they returned, this time with a search warrant.

Eight agents descended on Billy the Oysterman at noon and swarmed over the restaurant.  According to The Evening World later that day, “They discovered ten cases of whiskey and several barrels of bottled beer and ale of unauthorized but strongly verbalized authority.”  The New York Times reported “The total value of the seized goods at the current bootleg prices was given at $5,000” and increased the number of cases of whiskey to 25.

When the agents crashed into the private bar, according to The Times, “A patron…was about to place a glass of whisky to his lips.  The agent snatched it away from him and placed it with the other seized stuff.”

The Evening World said “The patrons of the place showed strong indignation.  Some were unhappy because ‘so much good stuff had to go to waste;’ others were incensed against the management because they had never learned that forbidden beverages were to be had in the place.”

According to the New-York Tribune “A crowd gathered and watched the agents load cases and barrels on a big warehouse truck.”  The newspaper provided a more detailed inventory of Billy’s stash.  “In the seizure were cases of wines, gin, whisky and cordials.  The beer alone was reported to be worth $5,000.  The liquors, including choice wines, were worth probably $5,000 more.”

By now Billy the Oysterman had taken over the former Holtz & Freystedt space as well.  The brothers--perhaps in part because they ignored Prohibition--were doing quite well for themselves.  The restaurant’s 1921 Profit and Loss Statement disclosed that George was earning $19,500 a year, and his brothers $12,000 each.  Those figures would equal about $240,000 and $150,000 today.  George’s salary was of intense interest to his wife, Florence, who began divorce proceedings in 1922.

Despite Federal raids, Billy the Oysterman continued on with relative normalcy.  The same year that agents made their noon raid, the Upholstery Association of America took over the second floor for its annual elections.  “Following the election of officers a beefsteak dinner and smoker will be provided by Billy the Oysterman,” announced The Upholsterer and Interior Decorator.

The Ockendons would not surrender in their battle against Prohibition. In 1926 the restaurant donated $50 to the Association Against the Prohibition Amendment.  And two years later George’s brother William got even with one government agent.

William was in the restaurant in June 1928 when undercover agents Palmer F. Tubbs and Samuel Kupferman ordered a drink.  When they were served, they identified themselves.  But Kupferman took William Ockendon aside and said he would “fix things up” for $500.  Ockendon paid the bribe.  Then immediately went to authorities.

On August 2 William Ockendon took the stand to testify as a witness for the Government before a Grand Jury.  In return for his testimony against the corrupt agents, he received immunity for the liquor sales.

George W. Ockendon died four months later in December, never to see the repeal of Prohibition.  The hard-edged and feisty restaurateur got the last word at least in one respect.  The divorce initiated by Florence was not yet finalized.  When George’s estate was filed he had cut her out of the will, leaving her a meager $500.

The title of Billy the Oysterman passed to William Thomas Ockendon, now the oldest brother.  The fame of the restaurant only increased.  In 1934 William Ockendon estimated he had sold 41,693,063 oysters; later putting the estimate into the context of a barrel a day—upwards to 1,400 oysters daily.  In 1935 Cole Porter wrote “A Picture of Me Without You.”  The lyrics included Billy the Oysterman:

Picture H. G. Wells without a brain
Picture Av’rell Harriman without a train,
Picture Tintern Abbey without a cloister,
Picture Billy the Oysterman without an oyster

William continued the family’s attention to fresh food and good service.  On November 19, 1934 his passion would nearly require that he be physically restrained.  The following day The New York Times wrote “An ultramarine-finned sailfish and a lean-jawed barracuda, both safely stuffed, stared fixedly last night from the walls of Billy the Oysterman’s…as the Society of Restaurateurs debated the merits of the table d’hote and the a la carte meal.”  The newspaper said “William Ockendon—Billy the Oysterman himself—was regarded as having struck the most telling blow”

The restaurant owners had come to decide whether offering limited menus of ready-made items would save them “from financial ruin.”  The very idea incensed Ockendon.

Standing before the association he said “I am 100 per cent opposed to the table d’hote meal.  I think it’s a joke—“  He was interrupted by an owner who said “It’s no joke; we use the same food for the table d’hote as the a la carte meal.  We—“

Now Ockendon interrupted in what The Times called a roar.  “There was never a roast chicken roasted at 11 o’clock to serve at 12 o’clock, that was good at 2 o’clock.”

When the debate between the two men verged on verbal violence, William Zelser of the White Horse Tavern “struck a conciliatory note.”  He soothed the men saying “There is room for both types of restaurant in this city.”

The Times ended its recap of the evening saying “Finally the echoes of the debate died away and the sailfish and the barracuda stared down upon empty tables and well-filled ash trays.”

Billy the Oysterman opened a second restaurant at No. 10 West 47th Street in 1938.  By now the restaurant was known nation-wide.  Forbes Magazine had commended two years earlier “Billy the Oysterman, like Oscar of the Waldorf, has become a national institution, foodwise.”

In 1938 the New York City Guide, published by the Federal Writers’ Project, listed the prices at Billy the Oysterman as “lunch from 85 cents, dinner $2.00.”  By 1946 when No. 11 East 20th Street was sold by the Fifth Avenue Bank of New York, the 47th Street location had become the main restaurant.  No. 11 was termed “a branch.”  Four years later Billy the Oysterman closed the 20th Street restaurant after nearly half a century of business.  The 47th Street operation closed in 1953.

A 1940s menu from the 47th Street restaurant mentions West 20th Street a "branch"

When William Ockendon died in October 1961 at the age of 80, The New York Times fondly reminisced of his passion for serving good food; and it brought up the heated debate of 1934.  “He once confessed that he himself was not fond of oysters and added that, perhaps, he had seen too many.  He was, however, a champion of the casual manner of dining and once lectured the Society of Restaurateurs on the beauties of the table d’hote and the evils of the a la carte fashions.”

The restaurant tradition at No. 11 East 20th Street continued when Miriam Novalle purchased the building in 1996.  She told a Times reporter ”I just want to be in the tea business.”  With Rhode Island restaurateur Hank Kates, she opened her tea shop, salon and mail order company called T Salon.

The centered entrance created in 1900 was moved to the side before the shop opened later that fall.  T Salon would remain in the space until the early 2000s.  It was replaced by ‘Wichcraft, a trendy sandwich shop that remains there today.  In 2009 owner Tom Colicchio expanded to the second floor, where dinner was now served with waiter service and wine.

Once a destination so well known that Cole Porter’s mention of it was universally understood, the little building at No. 11 East 20th is a bit sorry looking and mostly overlooked today.  Squashed between two towering buildings, it was the home of an important page of Manhattan’s culinary and social history, now forgotten.

photograph by the author

Thursday

The Ludwig Dreyfuss House -- No. 52 East 68th Street


photo by Alice Lum

Brothers David and John Jardine were highly active in the development of the Upper East Side where they erected rows of speculative rowhouses following the end of the Civil War .  The developers acted as their own architects and in 1879 completed a row of five brownstone clad homes at Nos. 52 through 60 East 68th Street, just two blocks from Fifth Avenue.  Four stories tall over high English basements, they featured dignified neo-Grec elements.

The houses at No. 52 and 54 were purchased by millionaire Anderson Fowler as investment properties.  Fowler had made his fortune in the West in the packing business and upon his retirement he invested heavily in mining and other industrial enterprises.  For his own family (which included nine children) Fowler chose another Jardine house, completed the same year, across the street at No. 41 East 68th.

On April 14, 1888 the Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide reported that “Ludwig Dreyfuss has purchased the four-story stone front dwelling No. 52 East 68th street.”  Dreyfuss had married one of the daughters of Marcus Goldman.  Goldman made his fortune providing diamond merchants and hide and leather dealers with ready cash in exchange for a note promising repayment plus interest.  The dealers in such promissory notes were known as “note shavers.”  Goldman was trading in as much as $5 million a year.

By 1885 Marcus Goldman had already taken Sam Sachs as a partner (Sam had married Goldman’s daughter, Louisa).  Now he also took his son, Henry, and Ludwig Dreyfuss into the firm, changing the name to Goldman Sachs & Co.

While Ludwig worked at the banking firm, his wife busied herself in worthy causes.  One of these was the Children’s Charitable Union, of which she was Treasurer.  The organization was founded in 1876 “to provide kindergarten instruction and classes in sewing for children of the poorer classes, without means to pay for tuition, giving them a warm noon meal.”

As the turn of the century arrived the brownstone house and its neighbors had become architecturally passé.  Dreyfuss commissioned architect John H. Duncan to modernize the home in 1900.  Duncan had designed impressive mansions, like the Philip Lehman house at No. 7 West 54th Street; but he was best known for his imposing Grant’s Tomb and the Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Memorial Arch in Brooklyn’s Grand Army Plaza.

Unlike some of the other radical make-overs on the block, Duncan’s renovations would leave no question that this was Victorian brownstone wearing new clothes.   The brownstone stoop remained, but was given new iron railings with a swirling French design.  Duncan carried out the Beaux Arts motif on the first and second floors.  The parlor received a vast arched French-styled window behind an ornamental grill.  At the second floor the original trio of openings was replaced by a curved oriel window.

A swirling grill protects the interesting French-inspired window at the parlor level -- photo by Alice Lum

There is little doubt that Dreyfuss instructed his architect to take the renovations no further.  The upper two floors retained their neo-Grec windows and the original bracketed cornice.  The result is a residence straddling two architectural eras; looking much like an unfinished project.

The Dreyfuss family lived on in the house for another decade.  Then on March 25, 1911 the Record & Guide announced that Ludwig had sold the house.   “The buyer will occupy,” reported the newspaper.

“The buyer” was Albert B. Ashforth, President of the Real Estate Board, President and Director of the Albert B. Ashford real estate company, and a director and trustee in other firms and banks.  Ashforth was not merely wealthy, he was descended from what The New York Times would deem a “distinguished old New York” family.  He was a relative of historian and intellectual Henry Adams, and he held memberships in several clubs, including the Union League, Bankers, and Automobile Club.  His love for golf was reflected in his memberships in the Greenwich Country Club, the Garden City Golf Club and the Blin Brook Club.

On January 3, 1925 the Ashforths' son, Henry, married Elizabeth Milbank Anderson in a fashionable ceremony in the Park Avenue Baptist Church.  A reception at the Colony Club followed.  The New York Times remarked that “The bride’s grandmother, Mrs. Milbank Anderson, was noted for her benefactions, having made large gifts to Columbia University.”

Three years later Albert B. Ashforth sold the house to his neighbor Margaretta C. Clark.  She lived across the street in No. 49 and bought Ashforth’s property “to prevent the erection of a high building which would seriously affect the light and air of her residence,” explained The Times on April 20, 1928.  The $125,000 she spent on the house would amount to about $1.6 million today.

A year later, on October 30, 1930, Silas M. Newton married journalist Nan O’Reilly.  O’Reilly’s astonishing career began at the age of 14 when she submitted a real estate article to the New-York Tribune.  For the next five years she was on the Tribune staff; then moved on to The Evening Post.  While there she wrote her first column on golf and forever after she would be associated with that game.  A year before her marriage to Newton she was made golf editor of The Evening Journal.  The newspaper introduced her to its readers as “The only female in captivity who has conducted a daily golf column.”

Silas Newton was an oil company official and a high ranking amateur golfer—the latter having resulted in the pair’s meeting and romance.  Although Newton was apparently highly successful, his fortune paled to that of his wife.  The New York Times said that “At the time of the marriage…it was said that Miss O’Reilly was heiress to an estimate of about $40,000,000.”

Above the updated lower floors, the Victorian house remained unchanged.  photo by Alice Lum
The Newtons moved into No. 52 East 68thStreet.  As what was apparently a wedding present of sorts, Newton purchased jewelry for his new wife at the auction of the estate of Rita De Acosta Lydig. 

Then, on Tuesday evening, February 10, Nan removed her jewelry and placed it in a case on her dressing table in the second floor bedroom.  The next night, while dressing for dinner, she attempted to open the case but found one of the catches stuck.  “One of her maids assisted her,” reported The New York Times.  “When it was opened Mrs. Newton found ten of the most valuable pieces of jewelry were missing.”

Some of the items were those Silas had purchased at the Lydig auction.  The Times said the total value of the ten missing pieces was about $15,000—about $215,000 today and quite a haul in the Great Depression years.  “The ten missing pieces included a pearl necklace, two bracelets and rings,” said the newspaper.

More trouble would come to the Newton household five months later.  On July 8 Silas was arrested “on a charge of conspiring with two others to defraud a 74-year-old man of his life savings, amounting to $25,000,” according to The New York Times on the following day.  Newton dismissed the incident to reporters, insisting it was all a misunderstanding.

“He took his arrest lightly and said the entire matter would be cleared up.  He denied any wrongdoing, and told the detectives that if the complainant thought there was anything wrong, he should have called at his office,” said The Times.

Silas Newton most likely began taking the affair less lightly when the state of New Jersey began extradition proceedings two days later.  In addition to the fraud charges, he was being charged with being a fugitive from justice in New Jersey.

The scandal was no doubt an embarrassment to Nan O’Reilly who, according to The Times in 1937, “contributed to, or otherwise worked for, every newspaper published in New York in the last twenty-five years.”  The couple’s marriage did not survive significantly longer.  Divorced, Nan died in 1937 at the age of just 41.

By 1943 No. 52 was the home of Dr. Francis D. Gulliver and his family.  Gulliver was a specialist in diseases of the eye and was the author of articles such as his 1942 “Particles of Steel Within the Globe of the Eye” published in a medical journal. 

The year 1943 was especially noteworthy for the family.  On September 5 daughter Ruth Ann was married to Charles Daniel Sullivan; and a few months later the engagement of Frances was announced. 

A year earlier President Franklin D. Roosevelt had created the SPARS—the United States Coast Guard Women’s Reserve.  Among the first enlistees was Frances Gulliver and by the time her engagement was announced she had risen to the rank of Lieutenant.  Interestingly, Frances outranked her husband-to-be.  Richard O. Jordan was an ensign in the United States Coast Guard Reserve.

photo by Alice Lum
In 1952 the house was purchased by the Marquise Margaret de Cuevas and in 1984 it was converted to offices.  Today the house with the architectural split personality is owned by the Center for Inter-American Relations.

Friday

The 1889 J.B. Layng Carriage House -- 172-174 E. 73rd



The block of East 73rd Street between Lexington and Third Avenues began changing in 1883 when millionaire Henry Marquanderected his handsome private carriage house among the brownstone houses.  Perhaps prompted by the odors and noises of stables, homeowners began moving away; their homes replaced by yet more carriage houses.  By the turn of the century the block was lined on both sides with the private stables of Manhattan’s wealthy.

Unlike most of the stables built on the block—individually designed for mansion-owners nearby on Fifth or Madison Avenue—the building that replaced the two houses at Nos. 172 and 174 East 73rd Street seems to have been built on speculation.  Designed by architect Frank Wennemer for Frank P. Perkins it was completed in 1889.  Perkins would not hold the stable for long.

Wennemer’s design was highly unusual.  Although the basic configuration fell in line with the expected central carriage bay flanked by a doorway and a window of matching size; the architect melded Romanesque Revival with the earlier neo-Grec style.  He made abundant use of rough-cut stone—comprising the base, the quoins and lintels of the openings—contrasted with smooth orange-red brick.  The heavy neo-Grec entrance framing featured hefty pilasters scored to insinuate fluting, and a fearsome beast’s head.


The newly-completed building was leased briefly to Ciancimino’s Towing and Transportation Company.  A few employees, like the company’s bookkeeper, Charles S. Fox, moved in upstairs.  Infighting within the firm may have led to its short stay on East 73rd.  On April 4, 1890 Peter Ciancimino was removed from his position as business manager by President Alrick H. Man.  Ciacimino did not take his dismissal well and continued to haunt the property, attempting to stay overnight, to gain access to the office after hours, and threatening the associates who lived there.  It all ended in an ugly court battle pitting the towing company against Ciancimino.

Before the year was up Perkins sold the stable to railroad magnate James B. Layng.  It was conveniently close to Layng’s mansion at No. 931 Fifth Avenue at 74thStreet.  He was not only Vice President of the West Shore Railroad, but that same year he was made Vice President of the Cleveland, Chicago & St. Louis Railway as well.

With its purchase by Layng, the carriage house took on the role of the others on the block.  The millionaire’s horses and vehicles were housed on the ground floor, while stable-related staff lived upstairs.  In the meantime, the Layng family lived and entertained sumptuously four blocks away.

James Layng was a widower and it was his grown daughter who took over managing the Fifth Avenue mansion.  On March 30, 1892 The New York Times mentioned that “Miss Layng, the daughter of Vice President Layng of the West Shore Railroad, gave another of her Lenten dinner parties last evening at her home, 931 Fifth Avenue.  The table was beautifully decked with daffodils by Dards.”

A month after his daughter hosted the Lenten dinners, Layng astounded the public when he predicted that the railroads would achieve speeds unthinkable to 19th century travelers.  Popular Science, in April 1892, reported that he “sees no more difficulty in raising speed to a hundred miles an hour than has been met in increasing it from thirty to sixty; and believes that it will be more difficult to get a track clear for the train than to develop a speed greater than now seems possible.”

The Layngs summered, normally, at Tuxedo Park and Narragansett, Rhode Island.  The tycoon was not just about locomotives and train cars.  He had a softer side that was reflected in his deep interest in cattle breeding and gardening.  In November 1893 American Gardening reported on the Bedford Flower Club’s annual exhibition.  “J. D. Layng took the leading award for a collection with plants of fair quality,” it noted, and added “In Roses and Carnations, J. D. Layng was a strong exhibitor and his blooms of Souvenir du President Carnot, Perle, Mrs. Robert Garret, and Beauty were excellent.  His Carnations embraced all the best quality novelties.”

In April 1899 the 68-year old James B. Layng retired from the general management of the railroads; although The New York Times on April 10 commented he “has not yet laid off the harness entirely.”  In the meantime the carriage house on East 73rdStreet continued serving the family’s transportation needs.  In 1900 census records showed that the upper floors were home to the entire Doughtery family—48-year old Rush, his wife Larra, and their two teen-aged children Lawrence and Lottie.

On February 11, 1908 James B. Layng died in the house on Fifth Avenue at the age of 77.   Calling him “one of the foremost railroad men in this country,” The New York Times added “He was connected during his railroad career with nearly every prominent railroad company in the East and not a few in the West.”

A year later, on November 10, 1909, The Sun reported that the Layng estate had leased the carriage house to N. T. Robb.  A major in the 12th Regiment of the New York National Guard, Robb had graduated from Harvard in 1893.  The banker was an officer in the Windsor Trust Company.
The estate sold the building on July 27, 1910 to John M. Bowers of the law firm Bowers & Sands.  On reporting the sale The New York Times noted “It will be used as a private stable by the new owner.”  The attorney paid $30,000 for the carriage house—about $710,000 in today’s dollars.

Bowers did not hold on to the property for long.  By 1912 it was home to the Kayton Taxicar and Garage Company, described by The Sun on July 30 that year as “engaged in the transportation and operation of motor vehicles for hire.”  Unfortunately for Kayton Taxicar, the firm went bankrupt that year.

The former carriage house was properly converted to a garage in 1919.  Meanwhile the upper floors continued to be used as residential space.  Here in December 1922 14-year old Molly Conway’s family was living when she wrote the winning composition on “Christmas Time in Our House” and won a silver dollar.

In August 1931 George E. Cook operated his business here.  He advertised his “Original Automobile Formulas” in Popular Mechanics.  “Have sold thousands of cans and bottles of goods made from these original formulas of my own,” he boasted.

Within the decade the upstairs accommodations were reflecting the high-tone flavor of the neighborhood.  Maude G. Robinson lived here in 1938 with her Eskimo spitz, Skippy.  In 1954 the structure was being termed an “apartment building” and in 1968 the Department of Buildings recorded its conversion to a single family home with a photo studio on the ground floor.

Today the ground floor where a railroad tycoon’s horses munched oats is home to the Scientific Introduction Service, a facility offering psychological counseling.  The eccentric exterior is nearly unchanged; a reminder of a time when this block of East 73rd Street bustled with grooms and stable boys maneuvering  the expensive horses and vehicles of New York’s millionaires.

photos taken by the author

The 1882 Harvey S. Ladew Mansion -- No. 813 Madison Ave.


Born in Ladew’s Corners, New York, in 1826, Harvey Smith Ladew learned the art of tanning in his father’s business.  In 1849 he married Rebecca Krom and the pair had two sons, Edward H. and Joseph Harvey, and a daughter Louise.  The year following the end of the Civil War, in 1866, the family moved to New York City. 

After serving as a principal in J. B. Hoyt & Co., Ladew struck out with Daniel S. Fayerweather, forming the partnership of Fayerweather & Ladew.  According to the 1897 Prominent Families of New York, the firm “attained the position of the most important firm in the ‘Swamp’ district of New York, and which controlled a large portion of the leather product of the entire United States, and had important interests in all parts of the country.”

While Ladew’s successful leather company was expanding, the Upper East Side was seeing an explosion of development and construction.  Speculative developer and architect Charles Buek was busy at work on Madison Avenue in 1881.  The head of the firm Charles Buek & Co., that year he began construction on six high-end rowhouses on the east side of the block between 68th and 69th Street, and two others on the north side, at Nos. 813 and 815.

Before construction was completed Harvey S. Ladew had purchased the hulking corner mansion at No. 813.  Clad in red brick and trimmed in brownstone, the four-story neo-Grec mansion sat on a brownstone basement.  The composition reflected the acute angles and incised carved decoration typical of the 1880s.  By the time the family moved in, in 1882, the children were young adults and son Joseph Harvey Ladew was attending Columbia College.

Prominent Families of New York remembered Harvey S. Ladew as “a merchant of the old school [who] wielded great influence in mercantile circles.”  Ladew’s great influence would soon draw to a close, however.  During the late winter of 1888 he became ill, and on Friday evening, March 9 the 63-year old died in the house.  Four days later at 10:30 a.m. his funeral was held in the parlor.

Edward and Joseph continued in the family business.  A year after their father’s death, Joseph took his brother in as a partner in Fayerweather & Ladew.  Both men earned substantial fortunes in addition to their inheritances.  Edward would go on to help found the United States Leather company, one of the largest enterprises in the United States at the time.

Joseph Harvey Ladew became well-known among the club set and held memberships in the Union League, New York Yacht Club, Larchmont Yacht Club and many others.  The New York Times referred to him as “the wealthy and well-known yachtsman.”  His love for yachting prompted him to commission the $200,000 yacht Columbiafrom the Crescent Shipyards in Elizabeth, New Jersey in 1893.  Joseph’s man-toy cost him about $5 million in today’s dollars.

The craft would have an eventful life.  Five years after it was launched from Philadelphia, Joseph Ladew turned the Columbiaover to the United States Navy for use in the Spanish American War.  The luxurious ship was renamed the USS Wasp and was used as part of the U.S. blockade of Cuba.  Following the war it was returned to Ladew and rechristened.  Then, in December 1901 the yacht underwent several weeks of refurbishing for a special voyage.

In November that year Joseph Ladew disappeared from the posh clubs he frequented.  “For several weeks Mr. Ladew had been missed by his friends from his usual haunts,” reported The New York Times on December 26.  The reason for his sudden absence was both surprising and shocking.  The newspaper explained “A Christmas surprise was sprung on the friends of J. Harvey Ladew…when it was published yesterday that on Nov. 27 Mr. Ladew had been married to Miss Jennie Bennett House of Rochester, N. Y.”  The Times said “Only the immediate members of his family knew of the secret.”

Joseph and Jennie had known each other for years; however she was married to Henry Hawkins.  When they accidentally ran into one another while traveling in the South—she accompanied by an aunt—Jennie had just obtained a divorce and resumed her maiden name.  “Shortly after the meeting of the two, an immediate marriage was decided upon,” said the newspaper.

Joseph quickly ordered that the Columbia be fitted out “for a protracted cruise.”  After a month’s preparation of the ship, the newlyweds sailed to the Mediterranean for their winter honeymoon.  The New York Times noted “Mr. and Mrs. Ladew will make their home in New York, at 813 Madison Avenue.”

In the meantime Edward Ladew had married Louise B. Wall in 1886, and Louise Ladew married John Townsend Williams.  Louise and John lived next door at No. 815 Madison Avenue.  By the time of Joseph’s wedding Louise’s daughter, also (and confusingly) named Louise, had been introduced to society.  In 1904 the debutante would become a bride in “The first big wedding of the season,” as described by The Sun on October 30.  Following the fashionable ceremony in St. Bartholomew’s Church, Rebecca Ladew hosted the reception for her granddaughter in the Madison Avenue mansion.

The wedding reception would be among the last entertainments Rebecca Krom Ladew would see in the house.  Six months later, on Wednesday, April 26, she died of pneumonia in Asheville, North Carolina.  “The entire family was summoned to the South,” said The Times on April 27.  Rebecca’s body was returned to New York and on Saturday, April 29 at 11 a.m. her funeral was held in the parlor where Harvey’s funeral had been conducted 17 years earlier.

Joseph and Jennie continued to live in the family mansion.  In February 1906 the couple had a scare as they rode in their stylish brougham.  An automobile frightened the team of horses and they panicked.  Coachman Thomas Burton tried to control the animals; but was thrown from the carriage when they veered sharply onto 92ndStreet at full gallop.  Still in the driverless vehicle, the Ladews were taken on a terrorizing ride that came to an abrupt end.

“Then they turned north at full speed and dashed toward a crowd of passengers just landed from an Astoria ferryboat at Ninety-third street,” reported The Sun on February 23.  “A policeman and several men darted from the crowd in an effort to head off the frightened animals.  The horses swerved toward the ferry house and crashed into it, one of them falling and the other barely missing a fall into the river.”

One of the horses was so badly injured that an S.P.C.A. agent who happened to be at the location advised shooting it.  Ladew consented.  The Sun advised “Mr. Ladew was not injured, but Mrs. Ladew was prostrated by the shock and badly bruised.”  The couple returned home to Madison Avenue in a cab.

In 1913 the family took the Columbia to Asia.  Included in the party were Joseph, Jennie, and their two sons, Joseph and Oliver; Edward’s daughter Elsie and son Harvey; and guests Hilda Holmes, Annie Wall and Juan M. Ceballos, Jr. the son of a Cuban banker.  Trouble came on June 11 when the crew steered the craft into the Wakayama port for repairs.  “Wakayama is not an open port because of its proximity to Japanese fortifications,” explained The Evening Independent of St. Petersburg, Florida.  Japanese officials were not pleased with the incursion and seized the vessel.

Joseph Harvey and Jennie Ladew with sons J. Harvey, Jr. and Oliver at the time of the Columbia's seizure.  photograph from the collection of the Library of Congress
The Los Angeles Times reported “The American Yacht Columbia, with its owner, J. Harvey Ladew of New York, and his party aboard, was seized today by the Japanese authorities at Wakayama.”  The Evening Independent was more concerned with the debutante on board.  Under a headline reading “Miss Ladew Was Aboard Yacht Seized by Japan”, the newspaper reported “Miss Elsie Ladew, one of New York’s most beautiful and popular society girls, is a member of the party on board the Ladew steam yacht, Columbia, which was seized by the Japanese government.”

Eight days after the yacht was “sensationally seized,” as described by The San Francisco Call, the newspaper reported that the Columbia had been released and was on its way to China.  The release had been negotiated by the Secretary of State after the seizure became an international incident.

In 1917 the Ladews added a penthouse to the roof of the mansion.  Designed by architect James W. O’Connor, it cost the family $5,000.  The following year, on April 27, the Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide reported that O’Connor had finished plans for additional “alterations and addition” to the house, costing $3,000.

But as World War I drew to a close Madison Avenue was becoming increasingly commercial.  By the spring of 1921 the family had decided to move on.  On May 19 that year the New-York Tribunereported that Jennie Ladew had leased “for twenty-one years her four-story and basement residence…to the 33 East Sixty-eighth Street Corporation, composed of several well-known physicians, which will alter the property into a doctor’s office building.”  The $300,000 21-year lease grossed the Ladews the equivalent of $175,000 a year by today’s standards.  To accommodate the medical offices, a storefront was added and the penthouse and rear extension enlarged. 

Joseph Harvey Ladew died on February 16, 1940.  Five years later, on September 24, The New York Times reported that “In its first change of ownership since 1880, the property at 813 Madison Avenue…was sold by the City Bank Farmers Trust Company, as trustee for the Ladew Estate, to the Tishman Realty and Construction Company.”  The newspaper noted that the former mansion “contains a store leased to Womrath Book Shops and upper floors are occupied by doctors.  The assessed valuation is $180,000.”


A 1946 photograph by Wurts Brothers reveals that the decorative brownstone elements had been shaved off to modernize the building.  -- from the collection of the New York Public Library.
Madison Avenue retained its high-end tone throughout the 20thcentury.  For years, beginning in the 1960s, the retail space was home to the showroom of designer Veneziano.  In 1971 the building received a new two-level storefront as high-end designer Halston opened his new salon.  Rebecca Ladew would no longer have recognized her drawing room or parlor.

New York Magazine described “ivory walls and cushions, carpet the color of wet sand, and mirrored walls, screens and plant tubs everywhere…Up the jazzy modern staircase, inherited along with slanting two-story windows from the previous tenant, are the more expansive cashmere sweaters and trousers which are the uniform of the Halston woman by day, and the sexy, wrappy jersey dresses she wears at night.  There is a studio for Halston and a mirrored room for private clients who don’t like to riffle through the racks.”

When Halson died in 1990 his boutique store was still at No. 813 Madison Avenue.  But within three years the building was purchased for $6.9 million by MaxMara, an upscale Italian women’s fashion company.  The new owners set architect Frederic Zonsius to work renovating the structure.

On January 2, 1994 The New York Times said “An old six-story building on the Upper East Side is getting a facelift.”  The newspaper deemed “Most notable will be the new limestone shop-front on the first two floors.”  Zonsius’s renovations would cost between $500,000 and $1 million.  The architect told The Times “We took old historical photographs and blew them up and tried to copy what we believed was there.” 



In a nearly unheard of restoration by a commercial firm, the decorative brownstone elements, shaved flat in a mid-century modernization, were recreated.  Considering such intricate research and care, the new storefront is somewhat surprising.  While not unattractive, the limestone storefront of engaged columns and pilasters under a frieze of blank discs has nothing in common with the house either in materials nor style.  Nevertheless, an enormous amount of the original Ladew mansion still survives—looking as much like a late Victorian apartment house as a massive single home.

non-historic photographs taken by the author

Thursday

The 1882 Mayer House -- No. 41 East 72nd Street



The rapidly developing Upper East Side presented enormous potential for developers in the late 1870s and early 1880s.  Speculators erected long rows of brownstone-fronted dwellings which quickly filled with wealthy merchant-class families.  One such real estate firm was Lynd Brothers.  Robert B. Lynd not only erected his speculative residences, he designed them. 

In 1881 Lynd Brothers began construction of a row of nine homes on East 72nd Street, from No. 39 to 55 in the trendy neo-Grec style.  Like its neighbors, No. 41 would rise four stories over a high English basement.  Robert Lynd decorated the window surrounds with incised carvings of whimsical stylized flowers, a nod to the emerging Eastlake movement.  Above the columned entrance portico would be a small balcony with a carved stone balustrade, mimicked in the areaway fencing at street level.  Heavy cast iron railings on either side of the stoop copied the design.
Fanciful Eastlake-style flowers decorate the window surrounds.  The cast iron balusters are capped by a brownstone railing.

The homes were completed in 1882 and No. 16 east was purchased by Louis Haas in February for $50,000—just over $1 million in today’s money.  By 1893 it was home to a well-known physician, Dr. Bradshaw, who put the house up for sale in 1899 as he prepared to move to No. 125 East 72nd Street.

It was purchased in April during a flurry of real estate deals that prompted The New York Times to comment “Seldom has a week produced a more interesting succession of dealings in fine dwellings.”  The purchaser was Bernhard Mayer who, along with his wife Sophie, was active in real estate.  This transaction, however, was not just another property deal.

The Mayers intended No. 16 East 72nd Street to be the home for their growing family.  The couple had four children, Joseph; Albert, aged 2; 4-year old Clara, and daughter Theresa.  Joseph would be the first to leave No. 16.  His wedding to Minnie Emily Gallert was held at Delmonico’s on the evening of April 4, 1911.

As World War I approached, Albert Mayer, who had attended Columbia University, was working on his civil engineering degree at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.  He graduated in 1919 and put off his career to serve his country.  That same year he was a Second Lieutenant in the Coast Artillery Section of the United States Army.

At the war’s end, Albert was listed as “general superintendent of construction.”  He would go on to become one of the nation’s foremost architects and city planners.  In the meantime, his sisters were growing up as well.

The same year that Albert had graduated from MIT 24-year old Clara Woolie Mayer was studying at the New School for Social Research.  It was a decision that would affect her life and the history of the university.


Entertainments in the Mayer home were normally understated.  But on Wednesday June 6, 1923 Sophie Mayer hosted a reception and dance in honor of Theresa and her finance, Milton I. Durlach.  The American Hebrew and Jewish Tribune noted that the groom was “of New York and Porto Rico.” 
Clara Mayer remained unmarried and continued her affiliation with the New School for Social Research.  In 1924 she became a trustee; and in 1930 she was elected secretary.

Somewhat unexpectedly the staid brownstone house would hear the laughter and footsteps of children again in 1942.  World War II was raging in Europe and Albert, now a Captain with the United States Army Engineer Corps, was married to the former Phyllis Carter.  Born in England, she was a stage actress who went by the name Phyllis Joyce.  In September 1942 she was a member of the cast of Noel Coward’s comedy “Blithe Spirit” on Broadway.

With Albert serving his country in wartime again, Phyllis felt a need to do the same.  She left the cast and announced she would leave for England to drive an ambulance for the Women’s Auxiliary Territorial Service.  But there was the not-so-small matter of the couple’s two children—7-year old Stella and 6-year old Kerry. 

On September 21, 1942 The New York Times reported that the children “will make their home with their paternal grandmother, Mrs. Bernhard Mayer of 41 East Seventy-second Street.”

As mid-century came and went Clara was left alone in the 72ndStreet house.  In 1950 she was made Dean of the School of Philosophy and Liberal Arts and Vice President of the New School o Social Research.  As the 1882 houses around hers were demolished or radically transformed; Clara changed nothing.

There are at least two other vintage dwellings in Manhattan that remained preserved in time because, like Clara, an unmarried family member survived for a long period of time.  The Treadwell House on East 4th Street and the Francis Huber House on East 17th Street are examples.  Immune to the changes outside their windows, the unmarried women lived on among their family heirlooms for decades.

The gas porch lights still burn after 130 years.

Nearly eight decades of Mayer life inside the house would come to a rather unexpected end in 1974.  Clara was a member of the Managing Committee of the American School of Classical Studies at Athens.  The school had no headquarters in the United States and for years the committee was concerned about its need for a headquarters in which to store records, and to possibly house the schools United States Publications Office.  The problem was financing.

At the May 1974 meeting of the Committee the issue was raised once again.  The 79-year old Clara Woolie Mayer proposed a solution.  She would donate her family home along with a $50,000 endowment.  In November the Board accepted the generous gift.  Clara packed the family belongings, many in the house since 1899, and moved to Los Angeles.  She died there at the age of 93 on July 20, 1988.

The blank white building to the left was originally a match to the Mayer House.
The American School of Classical Studies would share the house with the Royal Oak Foundation.  The group is the American affiliate of Britain’s National Trust, pledged to preserve historic properties.  In 1981 the Landmarks Preservation Commission remarked that the Mayer House’s “fine 19thcentury interiors survive.”  It remains a remarkable slice of 1880s New York on busy East 72nd Street.

photographs by the author

Friday

The 1870 Hotel Mumm -- No. 680 6th Avenue


In the years prior to the Civil War French immigrant John G. Torrilhon had established himself in the butcher business.  In 1860 the Thompkins Market opened near the Cooper Union.  It was an unusual cast iron-fronted building with a split personality.   The upper floors housed the Armory of the Seventh Regiment, while the ground floor served as a high-end grocery. 

In 1862 historian Thomas F. DeVoe recorded the scope of Torrilhon’s offerings.  “Under the stairway are located stands Nos. 43 and 45, kept by two Frenchmen, (F. A. Bailly and J. G. Torilhon,) who keep, besides pork in every conceivable form, boned turkeys, capons, larded bird-game, filet de boeuf, etc., many of which are cooked ready ‘for parties, breakfasts, dinners, or suppers, cold or warm.’”

In the meantime, to the west Sixth Avenue was developing.  By now modest homes had cropped up along the blocks between 14th and 23rdStreet.   The uptown movement of commerce was already making itself felt.   In 1869 Edwin Booth opened his colossal granite Shakespearean theater at the corner of 23rd Street and 6th Avenue and a year later William Moir’s expensive jewelry store opened on the opposite corner.  John Thorrilhon saw opportunity beyond the butcher trade.

The same year that Moir opened his jewelry store, Thorrilhon commissioned Julius F. Munckwitz to design a hotel at No. 680 Sixth Avenue.  The choice of architects was, perhaps, surprising since Munckwitz was at the time the Supervising Architect and Superintendent of Parks.  While working on Thorilhon’s hotel he was simultaneously designing park structures with Calvert Vaux and Jacob Wrey Mould.

A harmonious blend of Italianate and neo-Grec styles, the four-story building was faced in Ohio stone.  Each floor was separated by a projecting band course with another connecting each row of windows.  A handsome pressed cornice finished the reserved composition.

The Ohio stone, easily mistaken for marble, was carved with neo-Grec details.
Having established his hotel, the ambitious butcher branched out once again.  With a partner, John P. Dietrich, he opened a restaurant south on 6th Avenue at No. 344, listed in city directories as J. G. Torrilhon & Co.

Business in the new hotel was apparently good, for a year later Torrilhon brought Munckwitz back to add a two-story extension to the rear.  As the grand retail palaces of 6thAvenue crowded in during the last quarter of the century, the hotel got in on the act.

In 1887 the building was owned by John Parke.  He hired contractor J. H. Fitzpatrick to remove the street level façade and install a storefront.  While the Hotel Mumm operated upstairs, the first floor was rented out to retail stores for additional income.

Parke had died by 1899, but his family held on to the property and replaced the storefront that year.  Changes, however, were coming to the Ladies’ Mile.  In 1902 Macy’s Department Store leap-frogged the entire shopping district, closing its store at 14th Street and 6thAvenue and opening its enormous new emporium on 34th Street.  it was the first domino to fall that would result in the end of the Ladies’ Mile.

Unlike the blocks filled with grand emporiums, this one sprouted a jumble of small commercial buildings like the hotel.
The Parke family would own the building for decades, leasing the hotel.  As the neighborhood changed, so too did the character of the hotel’s operators.  John Heiser ran a delicatessen at No. 1543 Third Avenue in 1905 when he was suspected of complicity in the saloon murder of William J. Harrington, called by The Sun “a Bowery hanger-on and rounder.”

Heiser took over operation of the Hotel Mumm and things quickly went downhill.   In the years just prior to the war, the grand retail stores had nearly all closed and the forty-year old hotel was, at best, dowdy.  Heiser’s solution for the problem was to turn it into a disorderly house—or brothel.   A little cash supplied to Police Inspector James H. Gillen insured that there would be no disruption of business.

That all came to a screeching halt in the spring of 1914.  Police Commissioner McKay suspected graft and ordered a raid on suspected disorderly houses.  Among them was the Hotel Mumm.

While Inspector Gillen faced charges of neglect of duty and failure to enforce laws, Heiser had problems of his own.  On April 11, 1914 the New-York Tribune reported “Inspectors may come and inspectors may go, like Gillen, but the Hotel Mumm goes on forever.”  The article said that Lieutenant Dan Costigan’s “specialty nowadays is going around raiding places that every one except the police knows are running.

“Into his net last night fell the proprietor of the Hotel Mumm, one John Heiser, who can go into the jewelry business, judging from his appearance last night.”

At Gillen’s trial one particular witness testified about the hotel.  The Evening World reported “Women and men of bad character congregated there, he said.  He had observed many men and women entering and leaving the hotel without baggage.  Many times, he said, he had been solicited by women near the hotel while on his way to his studio.”

The hotel was converted to shops and offices and throughout the 20th century was home to an assortment of small businesses—dressmakers and embroiders, for instance, took space on the upper floors while various stores (one a china and glass merchant) occupied the street level.

After the dark period of the 1970s and 80s when the old Ladies’ Mile suffered neglect and misuse, a renaissance brought new purpose to the blocks of buildings.  In 2005 No. 680 was renovated to apartments—two per floor—and today a Chipotle serves Mexican food at street level.


Few would suspect that the staid stone structure once took care of the lodging needs of Victorian tourists and, later in life, satisfied baser desires.

photographs taken by the author