.

Showing posts with label mott b. schmidt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mott b. schmidt. Show all posts

Tuesday

The Lost Hahnemann Hospital -- Park Ave and 67th Street




A turn of the century postcard shows a tree-planted boulevard on Park Avenue.  The hospital's "outdoor cottage" can be seen at right.
In the 18th century nearly as many patients died of medical treatment or the infection resulting from operations as did they from disease.  The situation prompted famed British surgeon Sir Astley Cooper to announce “The science of medicine was founded on conjecture and improved by murder.”

Leipzig physician Samuel Hahnemann took a different path from established medical practices when he founded the system of homeopathy in 1796.  He stressed the importance of proper diet, exercise, improved hygiene and removing stress—ideals familiar in the 21st century.

Hahnemann Homeopathic Hospitals would appear in many of America’s major cities—Boston, Philadelphia, and Chicago among them.  New York City’s Hahnemann Hospital was incorporated early in the fall of 1869.  While it waited for a permanent structure, it used a rented house at No. 307 East 55thStreet as its hospital. 

The Hahenemann was a “free bed” hospital—meaning that those who could not afford care were treated as charity cases.  During its first year the hospital treated 40 patients; only one of which paid.

At the time Fourth Avenue above the Grand Central Depot was an edgy neighborhood of small butcher shops, groceries, unimpressive houses and train tracks that clattered down the center of the thoroughfare.  In 1870 the Hahnemann Hospital secured a lease from the city of twelve buildings lots for the term of 99 years stretching the entire block from 67th to 68th Street on the east side.  The Legislature granted the facility $20,000 toward construction of its buildings, on the condition that Hahnemann Hospital could raise an equal amount.

Like churches, privately-run hospitals used fairs and bazaars as a primary means of fund-raising.  The directors of the hospital went directly to the doors of the wealthy, as well, to secure donations.  By 1872 $15,000 had been raised and plans were in the works for the new structure.

John Francis Richmond, in his 1872 New York and its Institutions, described the projected hospital.  “The new structures will consist of a fine administration building, fronting on Fourth avenue, and of two fine pavilions extending one hundred and twenty-five feet along Sixty-seventh and Sixty-eighth streets.  The entire front on Fourth avenue will be two hundred feet ten inches.  The pavilions, besides high basement, will have two stories each, and a Mansard story, will accommodate one hundred and seventy-five patients, giving over 1,300 cubic feet of space to each.”  The cost of the completed complex was estimated at about $200,000—around $3.7 million today.

The planned buildings were badly needed.  By the time of Richmond’s description, the Hahnemann Hospital had treated over 40,000 patients and another 2,000 calls had been made by visiting physicians.

As later explained by hospital president Hiram Calkins (who, in an interesting side note, was present at the death of President Lincoln), with “the liberal contributions of the patrons of Homeopathy and a large sum raised at a fair, the construction of the Hahnemann Hospital on its lots was commenced in 1876.”  The cornerstone laying ceremony, conducted on October 25, 1876 was, as The New York Times described it, “according to the elaborate and impressive forms of Masonry.”

The complex and mysterious Masonic rites were completed when the Grand Marshall declared the stone “had been found square, level and plumb, true and trusty, and laid according to the old customs of Masonry,” said The New York Times.  Grand Master Ellwood E. Thorne explained “that from time immemorial it had been the custom of the Ancient and Honorable Fraternity of Free and Accepted Masons to lay, when requested, the cornerstones of buildings erected for the worship of God, for charitable objects, or for the administration of justice and free government, but of no other building.”

William Cullen Bryant spoke at the ceremony, saying that of all modes of charitable relief, the support of public hospitals was one of the worthiest and most necessary.

Even as the construction of the new structure neared completion, the ladies of the hospital kept up their fund-raising—now to procure the money to furnish it.  One event was held on April 26, 1877 when they hosted a “coffee party” in the 22ndRegiment Armory on 14th Street at 6th Avenue.  In addition to two hours of special entertainment for children in the afternoon, “good music will be provided, and from 8 to 12 o’clock there will be dancing for those who desire to participate in it,” reported The Times.  The newspaper noted that the funds go “to furnish the new hospital building on Fourth-avenue…which is now nearly finished, and which is entirely free from debt in every other respect.”

The following year, in October 1878, the hospital opened its doors to patients.  The bulk of the brick cube was largely unornamented.  A stone portico with Doric columns opened onto Fourth avenue (later renamed Park Avenue) and stone accents highlighted the openings.  But above the third floor cornice an impressive mansard level rescued the structure from mediocrity.  Severely angular and notably tall, its corner towers tapered upward.  Handsome dormers lined up around the roofline and especially high iron cresting capped the corners.

Additions to the main building quickly followed—first by an annex to the east, then by the construction in the side yard of a “cottage for a special class of surgical cases,” as described by Calkins later.  By the 1890s the cottage was being used for the Out-Door Department, “where a large number of the sick poor daily receive treatment and obtain relief,” reported The Medical Times in 1895.

Construction required more fund-raising and on April 21, 1880 the Hospital leased the old Madison Square Garden for a charity ball and art auction.  The cream of New York society was there and the following day The New York Times reported that “A pianoforte was playing a lively waltz, and among the dancers were persons well known in New-York society…In the Garden proper about 2,000 persons were about the various stalls of the Hanemann Fair, and numerous detectives from the Central Office and the Twenty-ninth Precinct kept watch.”  Children were enjoying a Punch and Judy show in one room.  And then the unthinkable happened.

Around 9:00 Mr. Story, who was in charge of the Art Gallery, noticed that pieces of plaster were frequently falling from the ceiling, accompanied by cracking noises.  He mentioned this to Detective Tilley and the pair decided it would be prudent to evacuate the gallery.  To avoid panic, the guests viewing the artwork were told that the heat in the room could be injurious to the paintings, so the gas was being turned off and the gallery closed.

The viewers left slowly as Story turned down the gaslights.  Just as the last one left a huge chunk of plaster fell from the ceiling—about 18 inches wide and several feet long.  Detective Tilley “saw what had fallen, and at that moment heard a frightful crackling noise all around him.  The ceiling appeared to open and then to slide toward the avenue, while the west wall tottered, gaped, and fell outward,” reported The Times the following morning.

Unaware, well-dressed couples continued to waltz in the dancing hall “until a few seconds before the second floor and the peaked roof with the tower fell into Madison-avenue.”  Two guests told a reporter “there was a puff, as of smoke, and a dull sound, as if an explosion had occurred, then crackling and groaning of wood and brick work.  Then the ceiling split, large pieces of plaster began to fall, and everything inclined toward the street; then came a terrible crash and the wall of the dancing-hall fell outward, and the sky and stars appeared.”

The Times reported “The immense throng on the main floor surged toward the Madison-avenue exit, over which bricks, plaster, and timbers were still falling.  A terrible crush occurred in the vestibule, and it seemed likely that a terrible panic was going to take place, and that many persons would be crushed to death.”

One young man clambered over the rubble and picked up a pair of cymbals, crashing them together to get the crowd’s attention.  He hollered for order.  “In the meantime the fear of the musicians had been allayed, and they were induced to play ‘Yankee Doodle,’” said The Times.  “The music stilled the crowd, and they left the building in comparatively good order.”

When the collapse seemed to have halted, “dozens of young men, fashionably dressed, began to explore the ruins up stairs a few seconds after the accident, in a stifling dust.  At least half a dozen persons were helped out of the wreck within a minute after the time of the falling of the walls.”  Tragically, not everyone emerged alive.  When it was all over the northwestern tower, the art gallery, the dancing hall and part of the restaurant lay in a pile on the street and three women were dead.  An injured man died later.

On May 3 the “grand fair” was reopened at the 22ndRegiment Armory.  Amazingly, some of the paintings on sale at the Madison Square Garden fair had been recovered, restored, and now hung here.  The high-tone nature of the fair was evident in the articles offered to donors.  “There are 80 valuable articles yet to be disposed of by subscription votes,” said The Times the day after the reopening, “including diamonds, pianos, a magnificent doll, with diamond jewelry, and a tiny wardrobe of 12 handsome dresses; an elegant satin quilt, an artistic screen, a very fine bicycle, oil-paintings, and a large quantity of silverware, besides many other articles of value.”  The newspaper noted that General Grant had outbid all competitors for a gold-headed cane.

Meanwhile, treatment of patients went on in the Hahnemann Hospital.  A peculiar set of circumstances surrounded the case of Mrs. Arthur Bloodgood in 1884.  The woman’s condition had deteriorated to the point that she was unable to move from a chair and her niece sat with her day and night.  Her physician informed her “that the only possible chance of her recovery would be a trip to California,” according to a newspaper.

The problem for the woman who now had her hopes for survival hinging on a West Coast trip, was that she was embattled in a divorce proceeding and had no money.  Her alimony case was tied up in litigation and “In the meantime she remains in a helpless condition at the Hahnemann Hospital.  She recently applied to her brother for assistance, and that gentleman sent her money enough to pay her car fare to California.  It is stated that each day renders her chance of recovery less possible,” said The Times on April 15 1884.

The newspaper explained part of the problem.  “Arthur Bloodgood, the husband,…is also a helpless invalid in Hahnemann Hospital.”

In 1889 plans were being discussed for a new, state of the art maternity building.  On March 21 that year The Evening World reported on the upcoming Centennial Festival for the benefit of the new facility.  “The affair promises to be one of unusual excellence, and a variety of attractions will be offered, including entertainments and performances during the afternoons and evenings.  A notable feature will be a ‘Martha Washington Drawing-Room,’ which will contain a collection of Revolutionary relics.”

The festival opened in May and featured a Russian tearoom where tea was served by girls wearing quaint Russian costumes, and the Martha Washington room furnished in 18th century antiques, including the chair Washington used at his inauguration.  A $4,000 punch bowl had been donated to be awarded to the most popular club in the city, as voted on by festival patrons.

By the time of this turn of the century postcard, additions to the north had been completed.  The cottage is now-vine covered.

The Egbert Guernsey Maternity and Children’s Ward was opened on December 18, 1894.  The $68,000 building (exclusive of land and furnishings) was the last word in modern facilities.  There were comfortable private rooms, bathrooms, and windows on four sides.  “Four private rooms have been daintily and completely furnished by Mrs. Guernsey, Mrs. G. W. Powers, Mrs. J. Neilson Stout, and Mrs. Ralph Trautman, with pretty rugs, draperies, pictures and bed furnishings,” said The Times.  “The color tones…are pink, white, yellow, and blue.  The rooms called forth many expressions of admiration from the visitors.”


The obstetric ward and a private room of the new 1894 Maternity Ward are surprisingly modern-looking.  photos from The New York Medical Times, January 1895 (copyright expired)
In 1905 The New York Charities Directory pointed out that the hospital accepted no contagious cases.  For those patients “in moderate circumstances” $7 per week was charged.  Private rooms for paying patients ranged from $12 to $50 per week—the latter amount translating to about $1200 today.  As always, those who were indigent were admitted and treated for free.  The figures put forth by the directory showed a marked change in charity-versus-paying patients over the years.  In 1901-1902, 997 patients were treated of which 683 paid in full and 29 made “small payments.” 

Some of the staff pose for a Byron Co. photographer in 1905.  Presumably the kitten was not on payroll -- from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW1PG4N8&SMLS=1&RW=1366&RH=631
The hospital was pulled into a sordid public scandal in September 1913 when Dr. John Husson and his wife appeared in court regarding custody of their 4-year old son.  The boy had survived with two broken vertebrae in his neck since a fall at the age of 18 months.  Dr. Husson pleaded that “only delicate and interested treatment will preserve his life.”

But the case earned lurid press coverage because Jennie Husson had earlier sued socialite Mrs. Louise Riddell Park for $5,000 damages for alienating the affections of her husband.  In addition to charging infidelity Jennie declared, according to The Evening World, “that her husband assaulted and struck her on Aug. 24 and told her that it ‘was only a light sample of what he proposed to give to her if she did not leave his household.’”

Husson, who was 20 years older than his wife, said he was merely trying to subdue his jealous wife during a fit of rage.  He explained that her out-of-control jealousy had damaged his practice.  Patients stayed away because “his wife was in the habit of calling at his office while he was treating patients and looking through the key hole.”


The hospital's kitchen as photographed by Wurts Bros. on February 1, 1917 -- from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW1PG4N8&SMLS=1&RW=1366&RH=631
On June 13, 1917 the Medical Record announced that the City of New York had sold the land occupied by Park Avenue land to the hospital for $100,000.  By now the Park Avenue train tracks had been lowered and covered over by a landscaped boulevard.  Mansions—like the grand Percy Rivington Pyne residence directly across the avenue—were rapidly replacing the older structures.  The value of the Hahnemann Hospital land had risen to $775,000.

In 1905 surgeons operate on a patient.  Rubber gloves, masks and hairnets are already in practice -- photo by Byron Co., from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW1PG4N8&SMLS=1&RW=1366&RH=631

Now that it owned the land, the Hospital directors knew exactly what to do—sell it.  On July 27, 1919 The Times reported “In a transaction involving about $2,000,000 the Hahnemann Hospital completed the sale of its property yesterday on the east side of Park Avenue, between Sixty-seventh and Sixty-eighth Streets, and purchased as a site for a new group of buildings the block front on Fifth Avenue between 105th and 106th Streets.”

The newspaper noted that the Park Avenue site, “one of the finest of the new large plots left on Park Avenue for residential development…is surrounded by some of the finest mansions in the city.”  The land had been purchased by a syndicate and “it will be developed in the near future with residences in keeping with the new house planned by Harold I. Pratt for the opposite corner of Sixty-eight Street, and the residences of Percy R. Pyne, H. R. Davidson, William Sloane, Arthur Curtiss James, the twin houses of the Redmonds, George Blumenthal, and the two Brewsters.”

Although the syndicate, headed by Douglas L. Elliman originally intended that the private homes of millionaires would rise on the site; the idea was scrapped in favor of a 10-story apartment building with a garden courtyard.  Designed by James E. R. Carpenter and Mott B. Schmidt, the handsome structure was completed in 1924.
 
Carpenter's and Schmidt's 1924 block-engulfing building still stands.  photo by cityrealty.com

Saturday

The 1922 Neo-Georgian Anne Morgan House -- No. 3 Sutton Place

photo by Alice Lum
In 1920 the two-block, disengaged section of Avenue A that ran from 57th to 59th Streets was not the sort of neighborhood where one would find wealthy socialites.   In 1883 the little stretch of roadway had been renamed Sutton Place, possibly with a nod to Effingham B. Sutton who had constructed a row of brownstone residences here in 1875.

Overlooking the East River, the area was home to the Peter Doelger Brewery, decaying rowhouses and tenement buildings.    The society women of Fifth Avenue had, most likely, never heard of Sutton Place and certainly had no interest in seeing it.   But that was all about to change.

That year Elisabeth Marbury, the wealthy literary agent and producer who had been born into an aristocratic family, commissioned society architect Mott Schmidt to transform a Victorian rowhouse at No. 13 Sutton Place into a Georgian residence.   She moved in with her long-time companion, decorator Elsie de Wolfe, and began a campaign of convincing her other female friends to follow suit.

One of those friends was Anne Vanderbilt whose husband, William K. Vanderbilt died on July 22, 1920, making Anne a widow for the third time.    New York society was shocked when, on January 9, 1921, a  New York Times headline reported that “Mrs. W. K. Vanderbilt to Live In Avenue A.”  She had sold the gargantuan Fifth Avenue mansion for $3 million to move to what the newspaper called “a little-known two-block thoroughfare.”     She used $50,000 of the $3 million to purchase Effingham Sutton’s house and, like Marbury, hired Mott B. Schmidt to renovate it into a 13-room Georgian mansion.

A society columnist abraded Vanderbilt for abandoning Fifth Avenue and moving to “the heart of the slums” and The Times worried that “Mrs. K. Vanderbilt plans to lead an exodus of society from Fifth Avenue and elsewhere to Avenue A.”

And, in a way, she did.

Anne Vanderbilt’s close friend, 38-year old Anne Tracy Morgan, daughter of J. Pierpont Morgan, announced her plans to have Mott Schmidt create a house abutting the new Vanderbilt house.  “Miss Morgan’s new home is being altered, to conform somewhat to the Colonial style of Mrs. Vanderbilt’s house, after which type most of the houses in the exclusive-little nook have been patterned,” said The Times.  “Many of the rooms will contain rare old paneling and furniture.  Some of these furnishings will be brought from abroad, but much of it will be Colonial.  It is expected that the cost of the site and the remodeling will be about $125,000.”

By now the neighborhood was filling with single and very wealthy women who were keeping Mott and Elsie de Wolfe busy changing 19thcentury middle class homes into fashionable neo-Georgian residences.   Anne Vanderbilt’s sister, Mrs. Stephen Olin,  was already here as were Mrs. Lorillard Cammann and Francis B. Griswold.

Two months later Mott Schmidt filed revised plans for Anne Morgan’s house at No. 3 Sutton Place.  She had purchased the house next door, No. 5, and the original plans were scrapped so that the two houses could be merged.  “The new plans call for the rebuilding of the two structures into a four-story dwelling in American Colonial style with a roof garden,” reported The Times.   Reflecting their close relationship, Morgan and Vanderbilt would share a common garden to the rear.

photo by Alice Lum
To create the illusion of a vintage home, Mott reused the bricks from the old buildings on the site.  And while the exterior impression would be 18th century, Anne Morgan would not have to endure the hardships of colonial life.   An elevator, in-house incinerator, gas furnace and refrigerators brought the home squarely into the modern age.

Mott based the design on two Philadelphia houses; the 1765 Samuel Powel House and its neighbor, the Benjamin Wister Morris House.  He treated the Morgan house and the Vanderbilt house as two independent but critically-related designs.  A critic assessed them saying “No more valuable or successful examples of the consistent and intelligent use of English architectural precedent in the designing of American houses are to be found than these two houses on Sutton Place.”

photo by Alice Lum
The house was completed in 1922 and House & Gardenpraised Morgan for her choice of 18th Century interiors.  “There are hundreds of beautiful drawing rooms in New York, but I know of no one but Miss Morgan who has determined to make the largest and most important room in her house an early American one.  She is using an old pine paneled room, such as were often seen in old Southern houses.  The New England pine rooms were usually much smaller and the paneling was generally more severe.”

The Drawing Room featured antique paneling and hand-painted French wallpaper -- photo Library of Congress
The establishment of Sutton Place as a suddenly-fashionable neighborhood caught on and in November 1921 Joseph E. Willard, former Ambassador to Spain, purchased the house next to Morgan’s and began remodeling.   But mainstream society was not quite sure how to react to this sudden explosion of female independence and rejection of tradition.    Rumors, started probably by threatened upper-class males, told of lesbian orgies in the Morgan House and secret underground tunnels connecting the women’s homes so they could pass back and forth unseen.

Whimsical, fearsome creatures flank the gates to the rear lawn that gently rolled to the river -- photo Library of Congress
While Sutton Place had transformed within two or three years into an exclusive enclave of millionaires, its recent roots were still showing.  An empty coal wagon lot where 57th Street dead-ended at the river had been used for years for a traveling carnival to set up.   And in July 1923 it was back, creating a stark contrast that prompted a New York Times headline to gibe “When Coney Island Came to Sutton Place.”

“On the corner of the lot, venturing out daringly on the closest point toward the most distinguished and formal of the elegantly precise Sutton Place residences—Miss Anne Morgan’s perhaps—the Ferris wheel, like a giant squirrel cage, reared its height above the housetops.”  The article teased that riders “dared to peek into the upper windows of a residential magnificence founded on preferred ratings in both the Social Register and Bradstreet’s.”

Photographer Berenice Abbott, a friend of Morgan's, captured the street on April 2, 1936.  The Vanderbilt mansion is at the near corner with Anne Morgan's house directly behind.  -- photo Library of Congress
But it was Anne herself who would sometimes be responsible for the upending of Sutton Place propriety.   Among her many causes and interests were the servicemen.   She had spent years in Europe during World War I working with the military and World War II would arouse her spirit again.   Morgan staged a block party for hundreds of service men on quiet Sutton Place just four months before the attack on Pearl Harbor would drag the United States into the conflict.

“The party got off to a good start at 8 o’clock,” reported The Times, “when the soldiers and sailors entered the front yard of Miss Anne Morgan’s home, which was decorated with red, white and blue electric light bulbs.”   The end of 57thStreet was roped off to create an area for dancing and the newspaper mentioned that “Soon many soldiers and sailors were showing the spectators lined on Sutton Place that the latest ‘jitterburg steps’ were not unknown to the men in uniform.”

The patriotic Morgan was a bit of a detective, as well.   The following year, in May, with gas rationing in force, Anne Morgan smelled the vapors of gasoline emanating from the basement of the house next door.  She notified the Bureau of Combustibles of the Fire Department who found 65-1/2 gallons of fuel stored in the cellar.  The neighbor, Mrs. Clarinne Reavis, explained that she was fearful that the rationing card she received would not provide enough gasoline for her duties as a member of the Mayor’s city patrol, a volunteer defense auxiliary.

The indomitable Anne Morgan -- photo Library of Congress
Morgan, perhaps, saved her own house from destruction, considering that Mrs. Reavis’s fume-leaking reserves of gasoline were stored about 50 feet from the open pilot light to her hot water heater.

Anne Morgan traveled to France when the Nazis invaded and formed the American Ambulance Corps.  The organization aided many Americans who had become trapped by the invasion.  She returned throughout the war and had just come home in September 1947 after checking on social services she had founded in France.   While at her Mount Kisco, New York, estate she suffered a severe stroke and was brought to the house on Sutton Place.

The amazing Anne Morgan would live on until January 29, 1952.  Her relief efforts during the two world wars had earned her a medal from the National Institute of Social Science in 1915 and she was the first American woman appointed a commander of the French Legion of Honor.  She had taken up residence near the French front from 1917 to 1921, forming The American Friends of France mostly with her own money.  It provided furniture to bombed-out families, created a health service, a mobile library among other efforts.

After her death, Leigh Mitchell Hodges wrote to The New York Times saying in part, “Only those who saw her in action [in France] could appreciate her courage, rare leadership and utter selflessness.  These qualities of greatness begat for her high and deserved awards, but of far more moment than medals and ribbons was the grateful love of a whole people.”

The house on Sutton Place was purchased that year by Arthur Amory Houghton, Jr., the great-grandson of the founder of Corning Glass.   Exactly twenty years later, Houghton donated the house to the United Nations Association of the United States.  The association leased it to the United Nations for a year as the home of the Secretary General, then sold it to the organization in 1973.

Today the stately home of Anne Morgan remains the home of the U.N.’s Secretary General.  Its colonial façade, along with those of its neighbors built by independent-thinking women who broke free of tradition, looks as though it has stood there for centuries.

Monday

The Vincent Astor House - No. 130 East 80th Street

photo by Jim Henderson
Vincent Astor was just 20 years old in 1912 when the Titanic sunk. On board was Astor’s father, John Jacob Astor and his new wife, Madeleine, who was younger than Vincent. Through tragedy the young Harvard student became one of the richest men in the world, inheriting an estimated $200 million.


The young Vincent Astor was neither short on money nor good looks.

Two years later Astor married Helen Dinsmore Huntington and, after serving in the Navy during World War I, began planning a permanent home. Collective eyebrows and curiosities were raised when the millionaire began buying up properties on East 80th and 79th Streets, a few blocks away from the more-expected Fifth Avenue.

On January 8, 1926 The New York Times noted that “The private residence at 127 East Seventy-ninth Street, between Park and Lexington Avenues, has been purchased by Vincent Astor, it was learned yesterday, and will be added to the plot he has assembled at this point for improvement with a new residence for his own occupancy.”

The “plot he has assembled” included the home of Mrs. Louis W. Noel at No. 130 East 80th Street.

Within the year Astor had commissioned the highly-esteemed architect Mott B. Schmidt to design the new mansion on the site of the demolished Noel residence. Giving a nod to Robert Adam’s elegant London Society of Arts Building, Schmidt created a restrained Neo-Classic residence constructed of imported Roche limestone, completed in 1928.

Oozing English understated poise, its stone portico rests on two plain, Ionic pillars – reflected in the four two-story Ionic pilasters above. Simple but graceful iron fencing separates the first floor from the public sidewalk. Schmidt, in foregoing elaborate ornamentation, achieved unparalleled class.

Helen Astor was a staunch supporter of the musical arts and entertained often in the mansion, hosting charity teas for the Philharmonic and, in October 1938, giving a gala reception for Arturo Toscanini before he left New York for Europe.

With the Astors came other wealthy neighbors as three Georgian-style brick mansions abutted No. 130. Comparing the Astor mansion to these homes decades later, the AIA Guide to New York City said it was the “most subtle and most powerful of the 80th Street Quartet. Here brick Georgian gives way to travertine Regency. Taut Ionic pilasters, and an elegant relieving arch in the manner of the Brothers Adam. Schmidt was a winner.”

Helen and Vincent Astor divorced in 1940. Before long Astor married Mary Benedict Cushing, best known as Minnie. Within two years he was breaking Astor tradition – after a century and a half of accumulating Astor property, Vincent began selling it. Among the properties he liquidated was the mansion at No. 130 East 80th Street.

photo nyjl.org
In 1943 Mrs. Bertha Rainey Plum purchased the house, living here just four years. Then in 1947 it was acquired by the Junior League of New York City. By 1949 the house was ready for their move. The Times reported on May 24 of that year, “The Junior League of the City of New York once more is dwelling in marble halls…after ‘roughing it’ for nearly a year in a storage warehouse.”

The League, whose purpose according to its Mission Statement is “exclusively educational and charitable,” remains in Vincent Astor’s exceptional mansion, preserving its integrity on a block of exceptional residences.

Wednesday

The 1924 Aeolian Building--689 Fifth Avenue


Street level is partially obscured in construction netting in early 2014 -- photo by Alice Lum

On his wedding day, November 21, 1895, when William Rockefeller, Jr. walked out of his father’s brownstone mansion at No. 689 Fifth Avenue, the neighborhood was one of refined residences and upscale churches.  Three decades would make quite a difference.

William Rockefeller, Sr. died in 1922, still clinging on to the old residence in a neighborhood now filled with commercial buildings and skyscrapers.  Only a few remnants of the old mansion district remained.  Among the bequests of his $200 million estate, Rockefeller left the house at Fifth Avenue and East 54th Street to his widow.  It would not survive much longer.

A sign hangs on the Rockefeller mansion, built in 1876, announcing its coming demolition -- photo by Byron Co. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=2
Already many of the piano manufacturers and dealers were moving north from the lower Fifth Avenue area to West 57thStreet.  Only Aeolian Co., manufacturers of player pianos (the Pianola Piano), would be daring enough to consider Fifth Avenue proper.  Like its competitors, Aeolian had already moved several times before the 1920s.  Now it would do so again.

In February 1925 the Rockefeller estate sold the old mansion to the Gould Realty Co. for $1.6 million—a significant $20 million today.  The New York Times called the property “one of the most valuable in the section.”  Within the month plans were announced for the site.

The Aeolian Co., signed a 63-year, $12 million lease for most of the building to be erected by Gould Realty.  The well-known architectural firm of Warren& Wetmore, which had just completed Steinway Hall on West 57thStreet, was selected for the project.  Like Steinway & Co., the new tenant would require a concert hall to market its instruments, showrooms and practice rooms, and the obligatory offices.

The architects presented plans for a 14-story structure in the "Francis I style" and construction began just seven months after the Aeolian lease was signed.  More accurately, it would be an elegant neo-Classical building with French Renaissance detailing. 

On the night of April 22, 1926, with construction well underway, fire broke out.  Members of the exclusive University Club across the avenue and guests of the Gotham and St. Regis hotels crowded windows to watch as the blaze spread up three floors and onto the roof of the Jewett Building at No. 22 East 54th Street and then to another.
The day after the fire the façade is smoke-stained.  Letters below the Fifth Avenue cornice read "Aeolian Hall."  -- photo Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=1
“The fire completely disrupted Fifth Avenue traffic at the height of the downtown theatre rush and brought prominent society people to their doors to watch the firemen battle the flames,” reported The New York Times the following day.  The fires were extinguished before long; but the damage was a setback to the construction of the new building.

Although the new Aeolian Building would not be fully completed until 1927, the Fifth Avenue Association did not wait.  It presented Warren & Wetmore the gold medal “for the construction of the most beautiful building in the Fifth Avenue district in 1926.”  The association judged 47 new buildings in the Fifth Avenue district before reaching its decision.

The Real Estate Record & Guide agreed, saying “The new Aeolian Building is a graceful addition to the music and art center which dominates the development of upper Fifth Avenue in the neighborhood of Fifty-seventh Street.”

The second story windows were framed with ornately-carved marble.  photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=1
The building was completed in January 1927 and within two weeks the Gould Realty Co. sold it to Celia Gould Milne (daughter of George Gould) for $3 million.  On February 24 the $1.5 million structure was dedicated.  Among the speakers was architect Whitney Warren who compared the architecture with music.
Musical motifs refer to the Aeolian Company.  photograph by Alice Lum

“Ancient traditions of pure melody clash along the avenue with the modern dissonance of jazz; the towering, aggressive structures of industry and commerce are like the clarion calls of architecture, all about us.  What to do?  Man is not always strident, the soul is not always in haste, the eye does not always seek the restless gesture of the skyscraper, never attaining its sky—a little rest, a little peace, a simplicity complete, a dream symbolized…by the sounds of lute and viol in castle parks.  I hope that the Aeolian Building conveys something of this.  In its interior it contains all that modern musical demands may require.”

The main showroom featured marble pilasters, crystal chandeliers and marble-tiled floors.  photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=1
The New York Times noted “The building, occupying a plot facing 50 freet on Fifth Avenue and 125 feet on Fifty-fourth Street, is designed with setbacks at the tenth, twelfth and fourteenth floors, and has a penthouse tower surmounted by a sloping roof terminated with a lantern finial.”

The Aeolian Building and Aeolian Hall would be about more than merely pianos.  Before long the firm dedicated showrooms to radios, the Aeolian “Radiolas.”  In 1920s America the radio was not just an exciting new form of technology; it was a piece of furniture with a choice of period-inspired cabinets that conformed with any décor.

The Hall sometimes doubled as a venue for temporary art exhibits.   On February 5, 1928 a private exhibition of works by Prince Jacques de Broglie was opened in Aeolian Hall.  “There are forty pen and ink drawings representing the history since 984 of the Castle of Chaumont-sur-Loire, home of the de Broglie family, a dozen unique clocks and some statuettes,” reported The New York Times.  “The clocks were designed by Prince de Broglie to represent various styles of art, Hispano-Moresque, Hindoo, Gothic, Louis XV, and others.”
Aeolian Hall set for a concert in 1927. photo by Byron Co. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=3
In August 1929 the building acquired its most important tenant (other than, of course, Aeolian).  Women’s cosmetics and beauty firm Elizabeth Arden took over five upper floors as well as a portion of the ground floor.   Founded by Florence Nightingale Graham (who took the name Elizabeth Arden) the company was an early example of a tremendously successful endeavor conceived of, developed and run by a woman.  To clearly identify the Elizabeth Arden entrance from that of Aeolian, architect Mott B. Schmidt designed an incongruous modern entrance framed in polished black stone at the northern end of the Fifth Avenue façade.

While Aeolian had been busy manufacturing and selling player pianos, Polish immigrant Israel Miller had been busy as well.  A shoemaker, he arrived in New York in 1892 and began making footwear for theatrical productions.  In 1911 he opened a small store on Times Square and in 1926, as the Aeolian Building was nearing completion, he purchased the property and expanded his store.
High above Fifth Avenue carved shells and festoons, grotesque faces and stone urns go mostly unnoticed from below -- photograph by Alice Lum

By the time Israel Miller died unexpected in August 1929 his I. Miller & Sons, Inc. had several outlets throughout Manhattan.  On December 13, 1938 The Times reported that the Miller shoe stores would be taking over the first floor of the Aeolian Building as well.  Aeolian moved on.  It had joined the piano firms on West 57th Street, leasing half of Chickering Hall.

“I Miller & Sons, Inc., dealers in women’s shoes, have taken the store at 689 Fifth Avenue on the northeast corner of Fifty-Fourth Street, formerly occupied by the Aeolian Company.”  The newspaper noted “This will be the third Fifth Avenue store to be occupied by the Miller firm and the fifth in New York.”

The shoe merchants announced that they intended to remodel the exterior of the building and “the interior will be rebuilt and air-conditioned.”  Changes to the ten-year old, award-winning Warren & Wetmore facade were intended to update the design.

“New windows will be installed, and the corner entrance will have one of the largest pieces of bent glass ever to be made and installed in New York,” said The Times.  The firm commissioned architects Robert Carson (for the exterior renovations) and Louis Freedland (for the interiors).

I. Miller Shoes scraped the lower two floors flat and changed the windows.  Mott Schmidt's somewhat obtrusive black doorway of 1930 is seen at left. -- photo by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915#/SearchResult_VPage&VBID=24UAYW5VAFZN&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=915&PN=3
Carson streamlined the classical-ornamented ground floor, eliminating the limestone pilasters, installing new show windows and a corner entrance.  The marble window framings at the second floor were taken away and the entire stripped-down two stories were clad in a grey-yellow marble.  Thankfully, the bronze garlands and scalloped window openings were preserved. 

Upstairs Elizabeth Arden continued selling cosmetics and pampering society women in her salon.  Even the Great Depression could not stifle the luxurious business.  On January 26, 1930 The New York Times noted that Elizabeth Arden’s Red Door Salon included “treatment rooms, rooms for exercise, tap dancing, and rooms for the use of the electric mask treatments and other innovations.”  In 1930 the corner door was painted a bright red for the Arden Red Door Salon.

In 1944 Elizabeth Arden purchased the former Aeolian Building from the Milne estate.  Arden and I. Miller shared the ground floor space for decades until the shoe company left in 1970.  By now Elizabeth Arden filled 11 of the 14 floors and the structure was universally known as the Elizabeth Arden Building and Arden's red door had moved to the main corner entrance.

Despite its now-commercial quality, Fifth Avenue was still the Queen of Avenues and its retail shops were exclusive and expensive.  The red-enameled door of Elizabeth Arden was flanked by two dignified doormen in grey livery.  Arden retained sole possession of her empire of cosmetics-related companies.  When she died in 1966 at the age of 88, she left a fortune of between $30 and $50 million.
photo by Alice Lum

Elizabeth Arden had not looked past her own death and left no provisions for the company’s continuance.   The government quickly laid claim to $37 million in corporate taxes and inheritance taxes and in 1970 the Elizabeth Arden firm was acquired by Eli Lilly & Co.  That same year Gucci elbowed its way into the famous corner store when Dr. Aldo Gucci paid a record-setting $100 per square foot for the space.

Developer Larry Silverstein had purchased the building that year and when Gucci announced that it wanted to redesign the space, he was concerned about preserving the integrity of the beautiful structure.  He brought the Elizabeth Arden executives and Gucci group together to share the costs and cooperate on the renovations.

Architectural design firm Weissberg Castro Associates was given the task of remodeling the famous façade.  Expansive windows were installed and the iconic red door was removed.  While the architects used high-end materials, the resulting ground floor transformation is a 1970s period piece upholding a 1920s gem—a possibly regrettable modification that we seem to have gotten used to.

photo by Alice Lum