.

Showing posts with label thomas lamb. Show all posts
Showing posts with label thomas lamb. Show all posts

Thursday

The 1889 Red Cross Training Hospital -- No. 233 West 100th Street


In the last quarter of the 19th century, architects filled the rapidly developing Upper West Side with delightfully fanciful structures.  Distinctly unlike any other part of the city, the streets in this section became a visual banquet of with turrets and towers, gargoyles and stained glass.  French townhouses sat side-by-side with medieval manors.  Here more than anywhere else in the city the architects exercised the freedom to experiment and test the latest styles.

In 1889 a three-story beauty was completed at No. 233 West 100th Street, just steps from The Boulevard (later renamed Broadway).  A city take on a suburban Queen Anne house, it boasted the capricious details that made the style so popular among Victorian homeowners—a bowed bay that morphed into a turret, half-moon windows filled with stained glass, creative brickwork, and decorative terra cotta panels.  A brownstone stoop led to the parlor floor above the English basement.  All that was missing from this urban version was a wrap-around porch with intricate woodwork. 

Two years after the house was completed, Clara Barton’s American National Red Cross Association founded the New-York Red Cross Hospital Association.  According to President Mrs. Charles H. Raymond, “The work of the hospital is to train nurses for indoor and outdoor work, no regular price being asked.”

An appeal for contributions for a hospital and training facility building went out and in 1894 enough money had been raised.   That year, in April, The New York Timesreported on the auction sale of the 25-foot wide house at No. 233 West 100thStreet; the new Hospital and Training School for the Red Cross Sisters.

In 1896 the Annual Report of the State Board of Charitiesnoted the extended work being done in the building.  Along with the training of nurses, it listed as its objects “to treat disease on most scientifically based methods, in particular without alcoholic stimulants, and to cultivate anything in medicine or surgery which may be of public interest or advantage.”

When the doors to the hospital first opened, Bettina Hofker was its sister-in-chief.  Among the original staff was Dr. A. Monae Lesser, the surgeon-in-chief.  Lesser was noted as “an advocate of surgery and the practice of medicine without the use of alcohol, and he has contributed articles to medical journals on these subjects,” said The Sun on August 8, 1897.

The close working relationship between Sister Hofker and Dr. Lesser fostered a more personal attachment and on August 6, 1897 the pair was married in the hospital by Rev. Dr. McNichol of the Fourth Avenue Methodist Episcopal Church.   Among those witnessing the ceremony were Clara Barton, and Stephen Barton and his wife.

The New York Times noted that “The wedding ceremony was very simple and followed a meeting of the Board of Trustees.  The President of the board, William T. Wardwell, gave away the bride, into whose purse the bridgegroom, following an old Manx custom, dropped a coin after the ceremony.”  (William Wardwell was not only President of the Board, but Treasurer of the Standard Oil Company.)

The newlyweds would soon take a trip to Cuba—but it was no honeymoon.  Rumblings of war with Spain resulted in a build-up of troops in Cuba.  In February 1898 Clara Barton sent Lesser and his wife there to vaccinate nurses and to prepare them “to be ready to start for the front on a moment’s notice.”

The New York Times reported on March 6 “Should war be declared against Spain, it will find the nurses and graduates of the New York Red Cross Hospital and Training School at 233 West One Hundredth Street, prepared to start for the front, for they have been holding themselves in readiness for the last two weeks in anticipation of a hurry call for their services in Cuba.”

Henry M. Flagler, who had been busy developing the coastal communities of Florida, gave land and $5,000 to the Red Cross to build a hospital in Miami, just north of his Royal Palm Hotel.  Twenty-five nurses from New York were sent to Florida in July to staff the new hospital.

Ironically, it was not battle wounds that the nurses were being primarily prepared to treat.    On May 22, 1898 18 Cuban physicians and 12 American doctors held at meeting at the hospital on West 100th Street concerning a greater danger:  yellow fever and malaria.  Dr. Emiliano Nunez, former director of Our Mother of Mercy Hospital in Havana, told those present that “at the present time fully 75 per cent of all soldiers from foreign countries coming to Cuba were likely to be attacked by epidemic diseases.”

The Sun quoted Dr. Juan D. Sollossa, in charge of the Red Cross in Cuba, as saying “As it is now of each 100 soldiers that go to Cuba twenty-five die from disease alone.  But this percentage could be cut down materially if proper hygienic conditions were established, as could be easily done.”

The Surgeon General requested that the Red Cross supply “immune nurses.”  In response an announcement was placed in the morning newspapers on July 19 that “applicants wishing to become nurses should be at the Red Cross Hospital” that morning.  Volunteers poured in from every walk of life.

Miss Dilworth told The Sun “For the most part the women who apply are attractive, able-looking women and full of earnestness…One has only to look at our volunteer corps, as they sit here listening to lectures about the proposed work, to see that they are a band of typical American women, women who are well and appropriately dressed and thoroughly accustomed to the niceties of life.”

One volunteer in particular was accustomed to the niceties of life.   The Daily Oklahoma State Capital reported that “Miss Margaret Chanler, great-great granddaughter of the original John Jacob Astor, has renounced society to act as assistant nurse in a Red Cross hospital ward, a sublime act of renunciation.”

The newspaper said “The suffering and dying to whom she will minister in Cuba will never know that one of the richest and bluest blooded New York heiresses is their attendant, for Miss Chanler desires to hide her identity when she dons the garb of the great order of mercy and the Red Cross sisters will respect her wishes.”

Margaret Chanler attended the classes at No. 233 West 100thStreet and witnessed surgeries.  Others were not so resilient as the wealthy great-granddaughter of William B. Astor.   During one operation “One of the society women fainted.  Several were forced to leave the room.  It was Miss Chanler alone who stood her ground and established herself in a distinctive niche for the admiration of the experienced nurses who witnesses her heroism.”

Another socialite who donned the nurse’s uniform was Mrs. Thomas “a wealthy woman, who has signified her intention of going where she is told to go and doing what she is told to do,” said The Sun on April 28. 

Sister Bettina told the newspaper “I would like it distinctly understood that we shall accept no more applications for war service unless the volunteer is willing to go where she is ordered, whether for relief work or field service.  A Red Cross nurse must be just as willing to obey orders without question, as a soldier.”

The patriotic fever to help in the war effort crossed gender lines and New Yorkers were surprised when The Sun reported on May 3 that “About fifteen men, in response to a wish recently expressed by Dr. Lesser, applied to join the Red Cross as volunteers to go to Cuba.”  The men’s entrance into the heretofore female-only field was gladly accepted.  That afternoon Dr. Lesser “gave them many practical and valuable points that will be of great use to them in caring for themselves as well as the soldiers, if they are ordered to the field.”

By the beginning of October 1898 all the nurses who had been sent to Cuba were back at No. 233 West 100th Street.  But they would not be here for long.  On October 2 The Sun reported that “The Red Cross Hospital at 233 West 100th street is removing to 259 West Ninety-third street, where there are larger accommodations.  There will be thirty-five beds, which will be ready by Saturday.”

The house-turned-hospital was sold at auction in May 1899.  In February 1900 the title was transferred to the Nameoki Club—the Tammany Club of the 21st District.  It was traditional for Tammany organizations to take Native American names and the Nameoki Club would offer a double-dose.  It was casually known as the “little Wigwam.”

The Nameoki Club was led by the powerful Matthew “Matt” Donohue.  A plumber, he rose quickly in the ranks of Tammany Hall, becoming the youngest man to sit on the executive committee at the age of 28.  By now the plumber had risen to the position of Superintendent of Sewers.  Donohue’s firm hold on the district was aided by the wealthy men who were listed on the club’s membership roles. 

One was candy-manufacturer George William Loft.  Broadcast Weekly said on February 11, 1904, “There is no more regular attendant at the Nameoki Club than George W. Loft, whose luscious candies have melted in the mouth of many a Democratic and Republican woman…He is one of the men who have done most to enable Leader Donohue to build up the big Democratic following in the district.”

Loft had a lot of irons in the fire.  Having amassed a considerable fortune in the confectionary business, he diversified into real estate, banking and retailing.   He was a well-known breeder of thoroughbred racehorses and represented New York in the United States House of Representatives.

The same year that Broadcast Weekly wrote about Loft, the Nameoki Club found a need to expand its headquarters.   On January 5 the New-York Tribune reported that the club “is to be enlarged and remodeled at a cost of $5,000.  The architect is Thomas W. Lamb.”   Lamb was best known for his designing of theaters and it is possible that it was at this time that the basement and first floor levels were extended to the property line with a brownstone addition, and the entrance lowered to sidewalk level.
The stoop was removed and an extension built to the property line.

The election year of 1906 was marked by an especially bitter race between Donohue and Ross Williams.  As the Nameoki Club prepared for its summer picnic on September 10, The Evening World predicted that the Williams followers would try to derail the festivities.

“A report gained currency through the district that followers of Ross Williams, Mr. Donohue’s rival for the leadership, would attend the picnic with a couple of vans loaded with empty-bottles, pig-iron and lemons.  Mr. Williams indignantly denied that any of his men would attend the Donohue outing so equipped.”

The Evening World also predicted that the Nameoki Club members would come home with hangovers.  “The leader of the band bears the suggestive name of Prof. R. E. Sause.  Tomorrow morning a lot of the merry-makers are likely to be under the care of old Prof. R-E-Morse.”

As it turned out, Donohue lost the election by eight votes after what The New York Times called “a long and tiring battle.”

The Club remained in the house until January 1913.  The building was purchased by Ennis & Sinnott, who quickly sold it within the month to Thomas Jefferson O’Rourke.  The Sun noted that O’Rourke “will remodel the building for business purposes.”   O’Rourke simultaneously purchased No. 232 West 101st Street which abutted the property to the rear.

By August the renovations were completed and half of the building--the entire third floor and part of the second--were leased to A. W. Brown.
Female faces stare out from the three intricate terra cotta panels in the curved bay.

By the second half of the 20th century there were just two businesses in the building, which had been allowed to substantially degrade.   Then in 1998 new owners John D. and Rosemary Kuhns completed a full renovation and restoration, resulting in a single family home.  The Kuhns replaced the slate-covered turret cap with a handsome copper bell-shaped dome.   Above it an eagle weather vane, while perhaps not architecturally appropriate, is an interesting curiosity.

The 1904 interiors, designed by Thomas Lamb, have been lost.  http://www.corcoran.com/nyc/Listings/Display/1007464
While few interior details survive, the remarkable Queen Anne house endures along with its equally remarkable past.

 exterior photographs taken by the author

Wednesday

Loew's Victoria Theater -- 235 West 125th Street



The once-grand theater sits boarded-up awaiting its fate -- photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com

In the opening years of the 20th century nickelodeons and theaters offered New Yorkers a fascinating new form of entertainment—the silent movie.  By 1910 more than a dozen theaters offered motion pictures along East 14th Street alone.

Marcus Loew was born on the Lower East Side in 1870, the son of Jewish immigrants.  Starting out as a newsboy, he worked his way up to owning his own newspaper and selling furs.  When he met fellow furrier Adolph Zukor, his life would take a drastic turn.

The pair established the Automatic Vaudeville Company around the turn of the century and opened penny arcades with hand-cranked “motion picture” vignettes.  As motion picture technology improved, Loew began purchasing established theaters and renovating them into actual motion picture houses.

Loew’s fortunes soared and before long he was constructing his own buildings; and his motion picture palaces were intended to outshine the best of the legitimate theaters.  In 1907 Loew joined forces with architect Thomas White Lamb to design his theaters.  The arrangement would be mutually advantageous and by the end of his career Lamb would be responsible for the plans of more than 300 theaters in the United States, Australia, India, South Africa, England and Egypt (not all for Loew’s, of course).

In 1916 Loew acquired the properties at Nos. 235 and 237 West 125th Street occupied in part by the 12th Ward Savings Bank.  And now Lamb returned to his drafting board to design what would be Loew’s Victoria Theatre.

On May 13, 1916 Exhibitions World predicted “Loew’s Victoria will be the last word in the theater construction.”  The periodical said the theater would be “devoted to high class vaudeville and the very best of motion pictures.”

The Harlem area around the site was changing in 1917 from the all-white middle- to upper-class neighborhood of a generation ago.  Black New Yorkers, in an attempt to escape the prejudicial treatment of landlords downtown began moving north around the turn of the century.  Even here, however, the blacks were taken advantage of.  Later, in 1939, the WPA’s New York City Guide noted “Barred from most residential areas in the city, Negroes pay rents 50 per cent higher than those charged for comparable living quarters elsewhere.”

Yet it was still a vibrant neighborhood and motion picture theaters were cropping up along its avenues.  For the Victoria, Lamb melded an Italian Renaissance Classical facade with British 18th century Adams interiors.   Completed in September 1917, its exterior was clad in white terra cotta.  A grand, soaring colonnade, two stories tall, supported a dignified paneled parapet.  Inside were wall murals and in the 2,394-seat auditorium, a large and striking ceiling dome.  The boxes were set within triumphal arches.  The final construction cost was $250,000—a significant $4.25 million today.



Terra cotta rhytons stand at the ends of the deteriorating parapet.  photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com

With the new Victoria along West 125th Street were Hurtig & Seamon’s New Burlesque Theater (it would be renamed the Apollo Theater later in the century), the Alhambra Theater, Proctor’s, and the Hammerstein Opera House.  The strip would become popularly known as “Opera Row.”

photograph Architecture & Building, January 1918 (copyright expired)

Opening night was on October 3, 1917 and it was noteworthy.  On the bill that night were the silent films Barbary Sheep and Oh, Doctor!  The stars of both, Elsie Ferguson and Fatty Arbuckle, were present.  Vaudeville draws Raymond & Caverly, known as the Wizards of Joy, presented their new act “The Submarines,” and The Hirshcheff Troupe played in A Russian Wedding.  Also present was Loew’s good friend Irving Berlin.

photograph Architecture & Building, January 1918 (copyright expired)
The Victoria opened its doors every day at noon and ran continuously until 11 p.m.  Admission was 10 or 15 cents in the afternoon and 15 and 25 cents at night.  For the price audiences could see two live shows per day along with the movies.

The popularity of the theater is evidenced by the take in the armed hold-up on December 6, 1925.  Assistant Manager Irving Plumer and cashier Ada Maurice were counting the receipts from one of the ticket booths in the business office.  Suddenly the window to the alley suddenly burst.  They were faced with a revolver thrust through the broken glass as the thug ordered them to turn over the cash.

“The hold-up man, a well-dressed youth wearing a cap pulled over his eyes, ordered: ‘Give me that money.  Hurry up; give here quick!’” reported The New York Times the following day.  Plumer handed the two piles of bills to the thief who fled down the alley into the night.  The take was $351—a substantial amount considering the dime and quarter admission fees.

Although the Harlem neighborhood by 1927 was comprised of two-thirds of New York’s black population, there were still a significant number of Irish residents here.  Problems came to the Victoria in August that year when the motion picture The Callahans and the Murphys was screened.  The picture had already aroused protests in other theaters and so on August 26 there were two patrolmen stationed outside the Victoria.  But inside, when a scene depicting an Irish picnic started, two audience members initiated what The Times deemed a “row.”

Mrs. Alice Tennyson and Mrs. Katherine Tennyson shouted “Are you going to stand for this.  It’s a disgrace to the Irish!”  The New York Times reported “The shouts brought more cries, hisses and catcalls.”  Two other women, Mrs. Anna Skillan and Mrs. Mary Monahan joined in the disruption.  The two policemen rushed into the theater and when the women refused to desist, they were arrested for disorderly conduct.

But in 1927 it was not discrimination against the Irish that was most evident at Loew’s Victoria.  Black patrons were permitted only in the balcony.  African-American jazz musician Garvin Bushnell had moved to Europe in 1925 to escape discrimination and had established a successful career.  Now he was back in New York and according to James L. Conyers, Jr. in his African American Jazz and Rap, he set out on his own personal campaign against segregation.  He did so at Loew’s Victoria by “sitting down in the restricted section, wearing a Homburg hat, speaking with a British accent, and daring them to throw him out.”

Although live vaudeville came to an end at the Victoria in 1930, the Great Depression years brought another type of diversion—the talent contest.  On week nights the Victoria, along with most of the theaters on Opera Row, staged local talent contests.  It was the beginning of a tradition that created a national name for the nearby Apollo Theater.

As it had done on opening night of the Victoria, the Loew’s Corporation drew audiences with live appearances by stars on premiere night.  The choice of stars in August 1940 could be argued as either demographic marketing or inherent racism.  While Eddie Cantor appeared downtown at Loew’s Canal Theatre for the premiere of Forty Little Mothers; it was not Jack Benny, but Eddie Anderson--who played Rochester--who was sent to Loew’s Victoria for the opening of Buck Benny Rides Again.

From the late 1940s through the mid-1950s the Victoria was the scene of the Police Athletic League’s annual Christmas party for the underprivileged children of the neighborhood.  Each year thousands of youngsters would file into the theater for free screenings and gifts and candy from the PAL.

By the 1960s motion picture attendance nationwide dropped as families purchased television sets and stayed at home.  In response, the Loew’s chain initiated close-circuit large screen television viewings of live boxing matches.  In 1962 over 2,500 patrons—mostly black according to the New York Post’swriter Ted Poston who was there—paid $6.75 to see the Sonny Liston-Floyd Patterson fight in Chicago.  Poston described “hundreds of standees…scores of others crouching in the crowded aisles and…dozens of teen-agers who had slipped through a back door.”

The scene would be repeated for major bouts like that 1966 Clay-Williams fight and the 1973 Ali-Norton bout.

By now the Harlem neighborhood around the theater was impoverished and crime-ridden.  And so when the Dance Theatre of Harlem threw a “gala benefit” at Loew’s Victoria on November 13, 1972, wealthy New Yorkers were concerned about political correctness.  The following day The New York Times remarked “But after many a white liberal discussion about what one should or should not wear to Harlem in 1972 (let alone whether one should go or not), the partygoers finally got themselves together.”

People like Mrs. Alfred Gwynne Vanderbilt, Mayor Lindsay, Rod Steiger and Brock Peters were present that night and The Times said “When they arrived at the brightly lighted theater, Harlem was waiting for them behind police barriers.  Black children in bell bottoms, teen-agers in faded corduroys and adults in the worn cloth coats of the poor stood six rows deep to stare, whistle, cheer and comment as black and white women in minks, sables and even chinchilla climbed out in the middle of 125th Street.”

The newspaper added “If either black or white guests were afraid of what might happen to them on 125th Street, nobody, including Mrs. [Oscar] Hammerstein, admitted it.”  Mrs. Harold Reed told a reporter “Someone asked me, ‘Aren’t you afraid of muggers?,’ and I said, ‘Good heavens, No.’  I said, ‘I’m wearing my best fur coat and my best pearls.  Harlem is not a jungle.’”

The following year iconic French entertainer Josephine Baker held a benefit concert at Loew’s Victoria to aid the Police Athletic League.  When a New York Times reporter somewhat oddly asked her how she found Harlem, the chanteuse replied “Well it was night, and we have a saying in France, ‘Every cat looks black in the dark.’”
 
By the mid 1970s the Victoria could no longer command the first-run films being shown in midtown.  Instead it featured “mostly Kung Fu and action movies,” according to Philip Morrow, the director of development for the Harlem Urban Development Corporation a decade later.

Finally, in 1977, after six decades of screening motion pictures to the Harlem community, Loew’s Victoria shut its doors.  It was acquired that year by the Harlem Community Development Corporation.  After nearly a decade of mixed use the corporation issued an announcement in July 1985.  Harlem was on staging a come-back and Loew’s Victoria would be part of it.

The $2.6 million renovation resulted in Moviecenter 5--five theaters and a small restaurant.  Then, on November 27, 2007 the Harlem Community Development Corporation announced its latest idea.  “The plan calls for a 40,500-square-foot cultural arts condominium, a hotel with 170 to 200 rooms and 91 residential condominiums,” reported Cityrealty.  “The arts center will include a 199-seat theater to be used primarily by the Classical Theater of Harlem, a 99-seat theater for the primary use of the Harlem Arts Alliance, 10,150 square feet for the primary use of the Jazz Museum of Harlem, and 4,000 square feet of office space for the primary use of the Apollo Theater.”  Lamb’s façade would be salvaged.

The ambitious project ground to a halt in 2011 when an Environmental Impact Statement revealed that water seepage had led to “heavy mold growth, potential threats to the structural integrity of the building and other defects which…threaten to seriously undermine the long term viability of this historically significant structure.”

Lamb's magnificent interiors and wall murals were heavily damaged by water infiltration -- photos Library of Congress
A revised project plan in 2013 suggested that “certain historic preservation measures” would be taken.  These include “restoration of its original lobby, façade, marquee and blade sign.”  Behind the lobby Thomas Lamb’s Adams-style auditorium would be demolished for a hotel and condominium structure and mixed use cultural center.

photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com

In the meantime, Loew’s Victoria sits boarded up.  Its once animated auditorium is quiet.  And the theater awaits its fate.

Thomas Lamb's 1928 Paramount Hotel -- 46th Street and Broadway


photo by Alice Lum
In the first decades of the 20th Century the theater district was establishing itself in the Time Square area.  Architect Thomas Lamb was busy designing ornate theaters like the Mark Strand, the Rialto and the Rivoli Theatres, all in the Times Square neighborhood.

A change of pace would come for the architect when Spear Construction Company bought up a group of small lots at 8th Avenue and 46th Street, then sold them as a package in 1926. Speculative investors Isidore Zimmer, Frank Locker and Samuel Reznick purchased the property with big plans in mind.

The New York Times reported that the team would erect an 18-story hotel costing $3.5 million called the Hotel Paramount. There would be 612 rooms, a grill room complete with dancing and entertainment, and a theater.

The lobby and mezzanine would be in the Spanish Renaissance style. There would be an intimate dining room for 22 patrons, and a row of nine retail shops along 46th Street. And theater architect Thomas Lamb would design it all.

The owners promised New Yorkers that the proposed hotel would “meet the demands of discriminating patrons who desire first-class accommodations at a moderate cost. This hotel will compare with the finest hotels in the city.”

The gargantuan structure, a story higher than originally planned, was completed in 1928, one of the first of the Times Square hotels. There were fully 700 rooms in the hotel and at the formal opening on June 5, 1928, 2000 keys were turned over to the custodians.

postcard from author's collection
Lamb combined his sense of drama so necessary in theater design with the lofty, elegant elements expected in a top notch hotel. His soaring French Renaissance pile sat on a series of two-story white marble arches that created the retail and lobby openings, crowned at the top by a massive multi-story copper mansard roof.

Terra cotta moldings, swags and keystones were reserved for the lower floors, visible to the passersby, while on the top most floors enormous urns, pediments and balconies drew interest from the distance.

Enormous urns, brackets and window pediments ornament the upper floors -- photo by Alice Lum
The grill room inside was modeled after a Spanish patio and featured dancing and live entertainment. The space was “cooled by refrigerated air” to refresh Jazz Age diners during the hot summer months.

The Grill Room featured top-notch entertainers and nearly was padlocked during Prohibition -- postcard from author's collection
Unfortunately, those same diners were refreshed by other means during those Prohibition days and in July of 1930 a padlock suit was brought against the grill by the Assistant United States Attorney on liquor charges. The grill managed to survive, however, and featured jazz performances for years.

A stylized, 1950s depiction of the hotel -- postcard from author's collection
Prohibition and the Great Depression dealt a serious blow to the Hotel Paramount and by 1935 it was in foreclosure; yet it managed to plod along through a series of ownerships.

Billy Rose, the Broadway song writer and impresario, opened “Billy Rose’s Diamond Horseshoe” nightclub in the lower level of the Paramount in 1938. Here “Billy Rose’s Long-Stemmed Beauties,” the chorus girls, performed along with some of the nation’s most celebrated entertainers; among them Dick Haymes and W. C. Handy.

The club inspired the 1945 musical motion picture "Diamond Horseshoe," featuring Betty Grable and was notorious, according to Ruth Prigozy’s book “The Life of Dick Haymes,” for “cheap food and drinks and scantily clad chorus girls.”

The Diamond Horseshoe continued entertaining tourists and New Yorkers alike until 1951.

Like many of the vintage Time Square hotels during the later years of the 20th Century, the Hotel Paramount suffered neglect, declining into a dingy and avoided relic by the time Ian Schrager and Steve Rubell purchased it in 1986.  Two years later Schrager closed the entire hotel for a year-and-a-half renovation. The exterior, not yet landmarked, was restored rather than modernized.  Schrager’s remodeling worked and, when it reopened, the hotel more than doubled its previous occupancy.


Two years later, in 1990, Schrager commissioned Philippe Starck to redesign the common areas and reopened it as the Paramount Hotel.  The theatrical, period interiors by Lamb were replaced with the sleek lines and bold tones that had made the designer famous. New York Magazine called it a “time capsule of late20th century chic…a grand staircase with a glass-walled banister touches down in a landscape of mismatched furniture – fuchsia couches, rustic armchairs, and sleekly lacquered mahogany desks.”

Philippe Stark's lobby design -- photo by Paramount Hotel
Again in 1998 a renovation was done, lasting seven months and costing $7 million, which included lobby lighting.

Ian Schrager sold the Paramount to Sol Melia Hotels and Resorts and the Hard Rock Café as a joint venture in 2004 for $126 million. The buyers did a $40 million renovation in 2009; the same year the building was deemed a New York City landmark. Stark’s lobby was modernized and public spaces totally redone.

By 2011 it was owned by Walton Street Capital and Highgate Holdings when, on February 11, Crain’s New York Business hinted that “The Paramount Hotel, a godfather of the boutique lodging industry, is going on the block.”

The hint came to fruition when in June German-born Aby Rosen, who already owned familiar Manhattan properties like the Seagram Building and Lever House, purchased the hotel for $275 million.

While the often-changed interiors are apt to get another make-over with the latest change in owners, the exterior of Thomas Lamb’s grand French Renaissance hotel remains unchanged; a dignified and lavish standby in the Times Square district.

Friday

The Glorious Loew's 175th Street Theater -- 4140 Broadway

photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com
In 1939 Thomas Lamb was far from his birthplace in Dundee, Scotland, on many levels.  In 1883 he arrived in New York at the age of 12 and went on to study architecture at the Cooper Union.  Eventually, after working as a buildings inspector for the City, he established his architectural office, Thomas W. Lamb Inc.

Lamb would make his name with the advent of motion pictures.  His first commission for a theater came in 1909 from motion picture magnate William Fox.  Within eight years he had designed three more motion picture theaters on Times Square.

By the 1920s movie theaters were rightfully deemed “palaces.”  And among the foremost architects of these lavish structures was Lamb.  Before his death in 1942 he would have designed more than 170 theaters.

When the Great Depression hit, Hollywood responded by cranking out carefree musicals and comedies with elaborate sets and lavish costumes.  Busby Berkeley’s Gold Digger series, for instance, offered depression-weary audiences an escape from the gloomy world outside the theater doors.  Even the lyrics in one of the Gold Digger songs, “We’re in the Money,” pretended the financial crisis was over with lines like:

“Old man Depression, you are through. / You’ve done us wrong.”
 and

“We never see a headline about a breadline today.  / And when we see the landlord, we can look that guy right in the eye.”

In 1929 Thomas Lamb would assist in diverting movie-goers’ minds from their troubles.  That year his Loew’s 175th Street theater was built at No. 4140 Broadway, between West 175th and 176th Streets.  Nothing the architect had designed before could outdo this latest extravaganza.

photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com

As if with gleeful abandon, Lamb’s wildly exotic design drew from nearly a dozen architectural styles.  Although The New York Times, on February 21, 1930, said “The house’s style of architecture is Indo-Chinese;” it went far beyond even that broad description.  The terra cotta façade—which smacked of a Cambodian or Thai temple--included elephants and Buddhas; and inside Moorish and Byzantine elements coexisted with stylized Rococo and splashes of Art Deco.

photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com

As he did most often, Lamb used Harold Rambusch, of the Rambusch Decorating Company to lavish the interiors.  Rambusch and Lamb shared an important theory about motion picture theater design—the audience should be drawn into grander and grander spaces.

In writing about the rehabilitation of vintage theaters, Janis Barlow of Janis A. Barlow Associates quoted Lamb who, in 1929, said “To make our audience receptive and interested, we must cut them off from the rest of the city life and take them into a rich and self-contained auditorium, where their minds are freed from their usual occupations and customary thoughts…it does not seem wise to bring the people directly into the full richness and intensity of the decorative scheme, so it is customary to work up to this intensity through various stages.”

On February 22, 1930 the theater opened with tremendous fanfare.  More than 1,000 Boy Scouts marched up Broadway from 170th Street to the theater.  “The parade represented the march of Washington’s army to defend New York against the Hessians,” reported The New York Times the following day.  Once in place, the assembled scouts watched the hoisting of the American flag on the roof of the theater.

Movie goers that day would see the screening of Norma Shearer in Their Own Desire.   The interior decorations, however, very well may have been the real show.  As the patrons entered the lobby they were surrounded by gold ornamentation, and red carpeting and hangings.  Intricate carvings encrusted the walls and ceiling.  The newel post lamps of the grand staircase were upheld by elephants.  At the top of the staircase was a gigantic mural featuring a bas relief Art Deco goddess.

Depression-weary movie goers escaped into an exotic fantasy -- photo https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/return-film-to-the-united-palace 
And, as Lamb and Rambusch intended, if the audience was awed by the lobby, they were blown away by the cavernous, richly decorated 3,400-seat auditorium.  Behind the pierced wall carvings were changing colored lights that created a magical kaleidoscope of changing hues.  Once they settled into their red plush seats, the cares of the Great Depression outside were temporarily forgotten.


Behind the filigree walls, lights constantly changed colors creating a mesmerizing effect -- photo by Tammy Lo

As with all the great movie palaces of the time, audiences were treated to organ music prior to the screening.  The size of a theater’s pipe organ was a source of pride as well as a marketing tool for competing motion picture companies.  The Loew’s 175thStreet Theatre boasted a Robert Morton twin-chambered “Wonder Organ.”

On Labor Day, 1943 Local Union 802 filed for a $12 weekly wage increase for movie theater organists.  Nearly a year later, on August 19, 1944, the War Labor Board approved the increase.  “The new scale of $92 per week affects only one musician at present, Henrietta Cameron employed at Loew’s 175thStreet Theater,” reported Billboard on August 26.  Henrietta received a windfall along with the increase.  “Miss Cameron has collected over $550 in retroactive pay from Loew’s,” the periodical said.  The organist was now earning a gross weekly salary of about $1,150 in today's dollars.

For another decade, before television kept families at home instead of at the movies, Loew’s 175th Street Theater screened first run motion pictures, Saturday serials, and newsreels.  Fans left the auditorium teary-eyed after watching Judy Garland in A Star is Born, smiled through Five Little Peppers at Home, thrilled at Son of Monte Cristo. 
 
photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com
As movie audiences thinned, Loew’s got creative.  In 1964 it screened live sports events such as the Liston-Clay heavyweight championship bout on in February; and the New York Giants and Redskins game at Yankee Stadium on September 25th.  On September 26th The New York Times reported “Pete Rozelle, the commissioner of the National Football League, watched the first quarter of the contest from a seat at the rear of the orchestra of Loew’s 175th Street theater, at Broadway.”

Tickets did not come cheaply.  The $6 cost to see the close-circuit coverage at Loew’s was the same price as the most expensive seat at Yankee Stadium (about $45 today).

Creativity did not save the majestic theater as a movie house.  In 1969, after the last screening of 2001, a Space Odyssey, the theater was closed.  It was quickly purchased by the Reverend Ike, considered to be the first black televangelist.  No store-front church, his United Palace had the funds to maintain the structure in its full glory.  Rather than alter the interiors Rev. Ike commissioned full-scale renovations that brought back the priceless Rambusch interiors.

In the early 2000s the church offered the auditorium as leased space.   Here audiences saw concerts by artists like Bob Dylan, Adele, the Allman Brothers, Neil Young and others.

Then, in June 2012, the United Palace of Cultural Arts—a nonprofit arts and cultural center—was created at the Palace.  The center hosts community arts programs, provides a venue for local artists to create and exhibit their work, and hosts events like the master workshop for elementary school students by the New York Philharmonic.

The church added the somewhat regrettable belfry; but was otherwise unusually sympathetic in the building's care -- photograph by Nicolas Lemery Nantel / salokin.com
Thomas Lamb’s extraordinary motion picture palace miraculously survives—one of America’s relatively few intact gems from the golden age of theater design.

Wednesday

The 1927 Loew's Canal Street Theatre -- 31 Canal Street

photo by LuciaM  http://www.panoramio.com/photo/34131029
During the first quarter of the 20th Century, the poor immigrant population on the Lower East Side could escape the squalid conditions that surrounded them in two places: the majestic churches and the sumptuous movie palaces.

Marcus Loew was born into this neighborhood in 1870. The son of Jewish immigrants he worked his way up from a newsboy to owning his own newspaper and selling furs. When he met fellow furrier Adolph Zukor, the direction of his life would take a turn.

The pair established the Automatic Vaudeville Company around the turn of the century and opened penny arcades with hand-cranked “motion picture” vignettes. As projection moving pictures developed, Loew began purchasing established theatres and renovating them into motion picture houses. Before long he was erecting his own buildings; one of which, the Loew’s Avenue B theatre was on the site of the tenement in which he grew up.

As the motion picture industry matured, feature-length films developed and movie theatres became elaborate temples to films. In January 1926 Loew’s company contracted architect Thomas Lamb to design a theatre at 31 Canal Street. Lamb had already established himself as a designer of theatres and for this one he produced an ornate terra-cotta clad façade, completed in 1927.

The intricate and beautiful terra-cotta upper facade of Thomas Lamb's Loews Canal St. -- photo by Alice Lum

Approximately four stories tall, the exterior was embellished with griffins, urns, festoons and garlands – a marriage of Regency elegance with Baroque abundance. The movie-goer would pass through the relatively narrow 22-foot wide Canal Street entrance and lobby into a 2,314-seat auditorium – the second largest motion picture theatre in the city. The interior space was decorated with lush terra cotta ornamentation and grand chandeliers.

While the Canal Street Theatre was a fixture in the neighborhood, it never showed the premier films that were relegated to the Times Square theatres. Here “B” comedies, westerns and serials played to masses of local residents before the advent of television. It was here, though, on April 17, 1940 that Eddie Cantor’s Four Little Mothers was premiered.

photo NYPL Collection

The last movie was screened in the late 1950s and Loew’s Canal Street Theatre locked the doors for good. After it was sold in 1960, the lobby was used as a retail store and the seats were removed from the sumptuous auditorium so it could be used as a warehouse.

The once-grand Loew’s Canal Street theatre, now a retail outlet for electronics, sat unnoticed until 2010 when owner Thomas Sung supported a feasibility study to convert the theatre into a multipurpose performance arts center.

That year the Committee to Revitalize and Enrich the Arts and Tomorrow’s Economy (CREATE) was granted $150,000 from the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation to conduct the feasibility study, The same year both the façade and interior were granted landmark designation by the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission.

Today while residents wait to see what will become of the once-proud theatre, dust continues to settle on the chandeliers hanging over crates of electronics. The ornate terra cotta detailing that once dazzled immigrant movie-goers remains in an astounding state of preservation.

Friday

The Remnants of the 1912 Audubon Theatre and Ballroom --Broadway at 165th St.


photo by wikiWhat as part of Wikipedia Takes Manhattan Project
In 1912, three years before he would immortalize his name by founding the Fox Film Corporation (later to become 20thCentury-Fox), the Hungarian-born William Fox embarked on an ambitious project in the rapidly-developing Washington Heights.  The area was ripe for a multi-functional entertainment venue and Fox sought out the services of theater architect Thomas W. Lamb to fill the void.

Filling the block on Broadway between 165th and 166th Streets, the dual-purpose Audubon Hall opened for business on November 28, 1912.  Lamb had created a 2,368-seat theater on the first floor, and on the second a “ballroom” and an assembly-type room that seated 200 persons.   Lamb lavished the two-story structure with mythological imagery and Roman-inspired motifs.    The colorful terra cotta façade featured griffins in the spandrels of the rhythmic two-story arches that defined the building.  Above the entrance an immense head of Poseidon served as the figurehead to an approaching Roman galley, before which a mermaid swam toward the passerby.

photo by wikiWhat as part of Wikipedia Takes Manhattan Project
Paired monumental Roman columns flanked the entrance and, with a nod to the dramatic arts inside, a series of lyres lined the grand arch.  Colorful satyr heads appeared throughout the design—over the entrance, within the lyres of the arch, and within the column capitals, for instance.

The architect strayed from the mythical theme by including full-relief terra cotta fox heads between each arch, an obvious nod to his patron.

Fox heads pay tribune to William Fox --photo by wikiWhat as part of Wikipedia Takes Manhattan Project (photo cropped)
Inside Lamb carried on the Roman motif.  Reportedly the auditorium boxes featured satyr heads flanked by maidens.

While vaudeville played downstairs, the Audubon Ballroom upstairs offered dance lessons, including all the latest fads, and events like dance contests.  The Ballroom was managed by George D. Grundy, a master of marketing who packed the space through special events.   He scored a coup in January 1919 when he lured the Dancing Carnival away from the Grand Central Palace where it had been traditionally held.

The Evening World, on January 18, reported that “The Audubon Ballrom of the Dancing Carnival, formerly at the Grand Central Palace, is being patronized by so many of its former friends that it seems like the original place.  The management has provided a place for the whole family to enjoy dancing.”

The newspaper went on to say that “The Audubon provides an evening’s amusement for slight cost.  Men are admitted for 40 cents, women 25 cents.  They can dance to their hearts’ content.”


Fifty-cents bought eight dance lessons in 1916 -- The Evening World, December 4, 1916 (copyright expired)
By 1921 the Audubon Theater was offering motion pictures as well as vaudeville.    One of the acts during Christmas Week that year involved trained seals.  Early in the morning of December 27 fire broke out in the cellar of the Corn Exchange Bank next door.

The fire spread rapidly into the Ballroom.  Meanwhile firefighters fought to save the theater portion.  “Firemen kept the flames from the Audubon Theater, a motion picture and vaudeville house, at the south end of the building, and rescued, much against their will, three trained seals which were backstage in their cages,” reported the New-York Tribune.

The New York Times reported that several firemen were hurt fighting the blaze.  The Ballroom “was put out of commission” and the lobby of the theater  was heavily damaged by water.

With the Ballroom repaired, George Grundy jumped at the latest fad of the Roaring Twenties:  the dance marathon.   The craze had swept the country’s large cities and young men and women vied to capture the endurance title.  The problem was that communities, including New York City, began outlawing the contests out of concern for the dancers’ physical well-being.

On Saturday March 31 at 6:57 p.m. Alma Cummings started dancing.  As George Grundy kept vigil, the 32-year old Alma (whose real name surname was Stappenback) danced the fox trot, waltz and one-step with one young man after another.  When the band quit for the night, two phonographs kept the music playing. 

Alma was a dance instructor at the Audubon Ballroom and 27 hours later was still hoofing her way around the floor.    On Sunday night the band which, according to The New York Times “had slept, eaten, been to church and returned,” played “The Star-Spangled Banner” and Alma Cummings was declared world champion (without police interference).  She attributed her success to being from Texas and “in part to nine years of vegetarian diet.”

The achievement sparked perhaps the most astounding incident in dance marathon history.  A month later a group of young people started dancing here in an effort to crush Alma’s record.  After 28 hours and 50 minutes there were still five men and three women dancing.  And then word arrived that the police were on the way.   Parents and friends rushed to obtain a moving van.  The phonographs were taken aboard and the contestants danced their way into the van. 

The hoofers danced inside the van as it took them to the ferry to New Jersey.  Once on the other side of the Hudson, another van moved them to the Pekin Dance Hall in Fort Lee, New Jersey.  But they were met by expectant police who made them move along.

Inside the van the dancers continued moving while they were transported to East Port Chester, Connecticut.  Local police allowed the last remaining dancer, Vera Sheppard, to continued until dawn broke on Sunday morning.  At that point they had to invoke the blue law and stop her dancing on the Sabbath.

Vera Sheppard had clearly broken the Alma’s record.  When she returned to the Audubon Ballroom (having danced through three states, a ferry boat and four moving vans) she received the unhappy news that simultaneously a girl in Cleveland, June Curry, had beaten her record.

The building caught fire again on January 12, 1927 while 800 people were viewing a motion picture.  As smoke entered the auditorium the patrons, many of them children, calmly gathered their belongings and filed out through emergency exits.  The organist, according to The New York Times the following day, played “Home Sweet Home” to keep the crowd calm.

“The lights of the theatre were turned on.  The doors were opened, and the wind carried in a great cloud of choking smoke,” reported the newspaper, “but not one person showed alarm.  Each walked out of the theatre in a normal way, and everyone reached the street without mishap.”

The three-alarm fire resulted in between $150,000 to $200,000 in damage to the auditorium and ballroom.  “The building, which is two stories high and of masonry, was burning throughout almost all its interior save the theatre auditorium,” said The Times.

Not all the events in the Ballroom during the Roaring Twenties ended happily.   On September 21, 1929 the Lantern Athletic Club hosted a dance.  Uninvited, 18-year old Betty Marshall and her date, 27-year old Jack King, crashed the party. 

The intrusion did not go unnoticed and King became involved in a confrontation with club members.  Shots were fired and Betty Marshall was shot in the chest and King in the shoulder.   Two stray shots hit the wall behind the pair.

When police arrived most of the revelers had fled and those who were left “could shed no light on the shooting.”  Betty Marshall was hospitalized in dangerous condition and, according to The Times, “The dance broke up.”

In 1946 the city was terrorized by a gang of youths ranging from 16 to 20 years old who committed thefts using two-way radios to communicate between the burglars and the look-outs.   The leader boasted he wanted to be the master mind of “the largest and brainiest gang in New York City.”

On April 30 that year the gang rented the Audubon Ballroom to throw a going-away party for a friend inducted into the Army.  The Times reported that they “invited 100 guests and made sure they had a supply of meat by stealing fifteen hams from the Swift & Co., plant at Twelfth Avenue and 131st Street.

“Needing funds to keep the party going, they broke into an automobile dealer’s office at 132d Street and Broadway and ‘cracked’ the safe, which contained several hundred dollars.  The party continued until well into the morning.”

A month later police arrested four gang members—two of them 16-years old, one 17 and one 20—for committing 75 burglaries, including 42 “safe jobs.”

After World War II the Audubon Theatre became the Beverly Hills Theater.  Later it was the San Juan, a Spanish movie house which finally closed in 1975.

Meanwhile upstairs, the Ballroom would earn infamy on February 21, 1965.  A year earlier Malcolm X had broken from the Nation of Islam, changed his name to El-Hajj Malik El-Shabazz and began presenting a less confrontational and separatist stand on race relations.   In response he received numerous death threats from the Nation of Islam and on February 18, 1965 told The New York Times “I’m a marked man.  It doesn’t frighten me for myself as long as I felt they would not hurt my family.”  He added “No one can get out without trouble, and this thing with me will be resolved by death and violence.”

Death and violence came three days later when the 39-year old stood up at the Audubon Ballroom to address the Organization of Afro-American Unity.    He was gunned down by assassins later identified as Black Muslims.  His death, however, became a sort of martyrdom that raised him to a symbol of black pride.
The stage and podium where Malcolm X was assassinated was photographed immediately after -- photograph Library of Congress

Throughout the 1970s the care-worn Audubon Ballroom above the empty theater was a favorite venue for prize fights.    Eventually, though, that too closed and, having been taken by the City for back taxes, the old William Fox Theatre Building sat empty and deteriorating.

Then, in 1983, Columbia University purchased the building for back taxes and announced plans to build “a space-age medical research center on the site.”

In reporting on the impending demolition, The Times said “The two-story ballroom on the corner of 166th Street and Broadway…was a major showcase for jazz, popular and bigband music during the late 1930’s, the 40’s and early 50’s.  It became the focus of national attention in February 1965 when Malcolm X was shot to death there.”

The announcement sparked protests from African American community activists, preservationists and Columbia University students.  Even after demolition began the protest waged on, with Manhattan Borough President Ruth Messinger among its most outspoken leaders.

An outraged New York Times called Messinger obstructionist and irresponsible and warned readers that saving the Audubon Ballrom “could hasten the decline of a deteriorating community and leave those who want to honor Malcom X, murdered in the ballroom 25 years ago, with nothing but a building in ruins.”

Despite the newspaper’s ranting, a compromise was reached to preserve about two-thirds of the original face and about 40 percent of the remaining Ballroom.   An excruciating $7 million restoration was initiated on the exterior and what was left of the Ballroom.

In 2005 the Malcom X and Dr. Betty Shabazz memorial and educational facility opened while behind the six-story Center for Commercial Biotech Research building, designed by Davis, Brody & Associates was erected.
The restoration brought the colorful terra cotta facade, nearly lost, back to life -- photo by wikiWhat as part of Wikipedia Takes Manhattan Project

The New York Preservation Archive Project notes that “the compromise exemplifies that preservation can work with new development by using innovative solutions for its protection.”

many thanks to reader Connie Allen for requesting this post